I'd be a rich man if I got one dollar everytime Super Techno Arts kept it's word. To be honest, they never promised much in years with regards to Robot Carnival, only vague notions of a tentative DVD release. This has been going on since January 2001, when someone posted info about it on Anime on DVD's forums (animeondvd.com) alongside the impending JoJo's Bizarre Adventure release which did eventually happen two years later after STA cancelled their distribution deal with Synch Point.
The only thing anyone knows for sure is that the U.S. once got a release of it thanks to Streamline Picture, but as with most anime in the U.S. during the 1990's and after Streamline went out of business in 1999, the rights have long since expired and/or changed hands.
E-mails are proof of nothing really. The proof will be when they 100% acknowledge they have the rights still publically at a con or in a press release and set a release date in stone. Until then, it's just rumors. I e-mail people lies all day. You should have posted the e-mail with full message headers so we could verify and hold them to account for it with fanboy furor. ;>
I second that ( and anime companies wonder why people buy bootlegs ) Like what I'm doing right now...watching a bootleg copy of Robot Carnival . I will buy the real version if they release it .
Sadly I caved and bought the version on discountanimedvd.com...I think it's a region 0 bootleg of the Chinese release. If Neo-Tokyo and Memories get region 1, why not Robot Carnival? It's absurd.
M'kay it's 2009 and it seems like we're no closer to a legit DVD release than we were 5 years ago. I agree with you locust, if we can have Neo Tokyo on DVD, there's no excuse for not having Robot Carnival by now. Whoever owns the rights to this clearly don't give a *beep*