MovieChat Forums > Nuts (1987) Discussion > Did anybody else feel an unadulterated s...

Did anybody else feel an unadulterated sense of disdain for Claudia?


I mean, I feel bad for her and everything, obviously it's hard to lead a normal life with a history like that. But I mean geez, do you have to such a *beep* to everybody? Especially people who will likely decide your future? She might not be crazy but she's certainly stupid. Everybody knows that the legal system is flawed, but you're going to get a lot further realizing that and playing along, rather than snuffing lawyers, making wisecracks every 10 seconds and whatnot. I had to watch this movie for psychology class and found it almost unbearable to deal with Streisand's insufferable character. In fact, I was almost rooting for Eli Wallach during the competency hearing, though I probably wouldn't have if I didn't always think of him as Tuco, one of my favorite film characters ever. I mean think about it, if you were in his shoes, what would suggest that she is the least bit sane? If somebody want's to be proven sane, but won't cooperate even to the slightest extent, what else can you do? I am disgusted and confused as to how they can even attempt to make Wallach's character seem to be the villain.

Just a terrible film, at least Karl Malden and Richard Dreyfuss were alright

reply

Well, I guess that it's a sort of tribute to the film's terrific casting that you sympathized with Eli Wallach's portrayal of the megalomaniacal psychiatrist, Dr. Herbert Morrison. He is a brilliant actor.

Regarding whether Claudia was sane: that was not at issue. She only had to controvert Morrison's testimony that she was incompetent to stand trial for manslaughter - as you noted in your post, it was a competency hearing, not a sanity hearing. It do that, she had to not only show that she was competent, but she also had to show that she had a viable defense in the manslaughter proceeding.

In a sense, her competency hearing was both a trial of her competency and her worth as a citizen. As it turned out, of course, it was also a trial of her stepfather, her mother, lawyers, and psychiatrists. I recommend that you also watch The Prince of Tides.

== One last note ==

You wrote: "...obviously it's hard to lead a normal life with a history like that." Claudia said: "...there is no order in life."

Interested in collaborative work on a new type of film rating system? Contact me

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I thought she was really stupid. In the play she was a law student. (I can't remember now if that was true in the film), but what kind of lawyer would she make if she can't control her mouth? I wouldn't want her representing me!






"Joey, have you ever been in a Turkish prison?"

reply

So the smart thing would have been if she just trusted the government (juridical institutions and procedures, medical authority, family values etc.)? I don't recall the movie stating that she studied law formally.

reply

I liked her and I would have liked her had I come across her in real life. Heaven forbid we should have a spirit eh?

'Well I've got two words for you - STFU'

reply