Am I missing something?


Uninteresting dialogue (and particularly unfunny and unoriginal scenarios; much to do about nothing), awful camera direction (composition is that of a blind person, one tilting shot of the sunset is particularly deplorable; basic back and forth discussion lacks spacial awareness), bad acting and characters (the protagonist is just too naive to exist), and all around poor particularly from a technical standpoint (I could light the indoor scenes better).

What's so good about this film again?

reply

Well, I was halfway through it when I stopped it to ask myself the same question you are asking right now. I decided to visit this board to help me find some sort of answer.

I am usually very attracted to films that feature unique cinematography and photography, like Lost in Translation for example, but this one seems to be lacking in plot or characterization in such a way that technical features just can't compensate. I am finding Polly a rather annoying character, although I can also see how her charm and child like innocence is quite uncommon and can be appeal to some. I guess it is especially hard for me to relate to such a completely aimless and "ambitiousless" kind of character--with too little sense of herself and her beliefs/values to even call her a free spirit-- and who is so disconnected from the world at large. There also isn't any kind of conflict to be resolved, like no sense of twists or turns or any anticipation to drive the scenario.

I do enjoy the camera angles and the way that images are Polly's sort of filter of reality so I will watch the rest of it and try not to give up!

But right now, I am also wondering what it is I don't get.

reply

I loved it. Maybe because I am dreamy person myself, like Polly was.

I think those who are rational thinkers, who can not abstract themselves from real word or simply can't stand Polly's type of people should not bother to watch this movie.

reply

Zichi, I think that's it. Not every film is geared to every type of temperament. As a fellow dreamer, I share your love of this film; but I can also see how others of a different mind could easily find it unappealing.

reply

The final shot with the door makes it all worth it.

reply