MovieChat Forums > Au revoir les enfants (1988) Discussion > Reading out the children's names (spoile...

Reading out the children's names (spoilers)


why do the nazis start calling out the non-jewish children's names and lining them up at the end?

reply

The Gestapo Agent also said that they were trying to get the foreigners out of France, so I thought maybe they were foreigners.

reply

Perhaps, but I recall that the Nazis, in reality, also rounded up Jewish foreigners regardless and sent them on to the ghettos or camps.

reply

why do the nazis start calling out the non-jewish children's names and lining them up at the end?





Dr. Muller from the Gestapo isn't convinced that all the remaining children are non-Jewish; after all, he makes the following comments when they're lined up in the courtyard -

DR. MULLER: Are there any other Jews among you? Answer me! (Addressing one boy in particular) What about you? Sure you're not Jewish?
I always got the impression that some of the children's names aroused Muller's suspicion (this would explain why he wanted to examine them more closely). It's ironic that Babinot was one of the children whose name was called, since he was one of the few students who spoke with disdain about Jews; he also came from a family that fully supported France's collaboration with the Nazis.

reply

murph24 says > Dr. Muller from the Gestapo isn't convinced that all the remaining children are non-Jewish. (Addressing one boy in particular) What about you? Sure you're not Jewish?
I think you're right. The Nazi's hatred ran so deep and so strong they were probably making sure they got anyone whose name may not have been typically Jewish or didn't sound Jewish but were at least partially Jewish.

Also, the Nazis didn't only target Jews. There were other groups they despised and sought to eliminate too. There were also many informants who reported people for whatever reason. They might say they were political or hiding and helping Jews when really they might have had a person dispute with the person or their family.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply

The kid he questioned more closely fitted the Jewish stereotype in his facial appearance.

"Chicken soup - with a *beep* straw."

reply

stevekaczynski says > The kid he questioned more closely fitted the Jewish stereotype in his facial appearance.
While those Nazi freaks did rely on many measuring techniques to determine race, I didn't think those were applied in the case of these boys. I suppose they could say the same thing you're saying, he looked Jewish, but weren't all the names already on the lists when they arrived?

They seem to have done their homework, finding out the backgrounds of the kids. As I recall, they only asked questions to intimidate the kids and get them to turn on each other. Then again, it has been a while since I saw the movie.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply

Probably they had the names, but they were nothing if not thorough and lined the remaining ones up and read out their names as a way of taking stock and making sure no other Jews were slipping through the net. Making them stand against a wall also contained the implied threat that they might be shot.

"Chicken soup - with a *beep* straw."

reply

That's for sure! The Nazis, like other similarly evil groups, took every opportunity to torture and try to break people down. It didn't matter that they were dealing with kids.

It's obvious what they did to those they considered their enemies but we cannot forget the evil they perpetrated on those they considered their own people too. They tapped into the darkest parts of their souls and somehow convinced them it was, not only acceptable but, necessary to treat other people the way they did. Even those who sat idly by and did nothing in the face of such evil were evil themselves.


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply