MovieChat Forums > Combat Shock (1986) Discussion > why was the sour milk drinking scene cut...

why was the sour milk drinking scene cut on the dvd version


?????????? anyone know?

reply

I thought the DVD was uncut.huh?

reply

It says over on the Tromatized site that the drinking scene was cut by the director from the film.

reply

-------SPOILERS-------

The sour milk drinking scene is in the dvd I think. I can remember when he goes in the kitchen he pours it, Takes a couple of drinks. Then blows his brains out.


We came to smash everything and ruin your life. God sent us.

reply

[deleted]

I think they gave it an NC-17 rating for that scene.

These cartoons are truly bizarre and frightening!
http://www.lungsfilms.cjb.net/

reply

Troma is planning on making a 20 year anneversary which will have 2 discs (one even having the orignal 'American Nightmare' cut of the film).

"You Can't Stop Me. I'm the Messenger"
www.slasherdome2.cjb.net
www.ibs-entertainment.tk

reply

wow thats interesting.

"how about... a royal flush!" *loren avedon kicks a cauldron of boiling water into the bad guys*

reply

Hey there, everybody, this is Buddy Giovinazzo and I'm so happy to be reading your comments on COMBAT SHOCK. Believe me, both good and bad comments are valid and I agree with most of them, although of course I have a somewhat different perspective. I wanted to set the record straight on the "uncut" dvd release of the film. I was shocked and upset when I finally got to see the "uncut" version, because to be truthful, it contained even less footage than the video version. I'm at a complete loss as to explain it, as Lloyd Kaufman is a friend of mine and actually really loved the film as it was. That's the truth, Lloyd was a champion of this film from the moment he saw it. What I think happened is that some film geek in the Troma editing suites got his hands on it and thought he would impress his bosses by making the film better. Some of the cuts are imcomprehensible to me, sometimes major story points have been cut out.

Last October Troma renewed the rights to COMBAT SHOCK and Lloyd promised me that a new, truly "uncut" director's version would be released. I hope when that happens it will shed a little more light on some of the things that work, and don't work, in COMBAT SHOCK.

I was a film student when I made the film, and now looking back I can see how embarrassing some of my choices were. It just goes to show that sometimes if your heart is in the right place, an audience will see through the mistakes and inexperience and find the heart and soul of a film. I lived that film for over two years, and I thank everyone who still gives it a viewing and a comment. For me it's not important if the film is considered good or bad, the fact is, after twenty years it's still out there, and for a tiny little student film made at the College of Staten Island, I got much more out of the experience that I could ever express.

Thank you all and take care,
Buddy

reply

[deleted]

not true at all! some film student at troma decided to cut up the film, not only for length, but because he thought he could improve the film. the uncut director's cut, is anything but. lloyd kaufman at troma promised me he would release a twenty year anniversary version of the film that would be completely my own. the very original film i shot in 1986.

i apologized to anyone who's been mislead by the director's cut. i was as shocked as anyone else by it. why would a so called director's cut be shorter than the theatrical version? no reason.

buddy giovinazzo

reply

I live in Chicago, This was playing at Delilah's ( a bar) last night and it was a dvd version and it did indeed have the sour milk scene at the end.... Now I don't know which version it was claiming to be. but I do believe that is was included on a disc of 3 or 4 other films.. because I thought I seen Nekromanik on the menu listing.


Be careful what you wish for...

reply

For the record, the sour milk drinking scene isn't the one in the ending: it's toward the beginning. Frankie says "Hey, we got some milk left" and is then told to drink it, only to shout "Why didn't you tell me it was sour?"

It sets up the milk drinking scene at the film's climax, which was left in. You can tell any cuts to the original DVD, because there are video artifacts present right after the cuts. This version is still intact as the "theatrical cut" on the 2-disc set, but the Troma Collectors Edition VHS from the '90s is the only way to see the fully-uncut Troma revision of COMBAT SHOCK.

reply