Suitable for kids?


I heard there is a scene at the end of the movie. How bad is it? Is it suitable for a 9 year old?

reply

There is indeed a scene at the end of the movie. There is also a scene at the beginning of the movie, and in between there are a great many scenes. This is the normal situation in movies. Do you not watch many?

As to how "bad" it is, I think it's fair to say that the film received a critical mauling at the time, but recently has experienced some positive reappraisals. Some have even seen it as an influence on the work of Baz Luhrmann. So, in answer to your question, "not as bad as we thought at first".

And finally, the killer q, "is it suitable for a 9 year old". Well, that really depends on the 9 year old in question. If he or she has been brought up in a culturally stimulating environment, with access to different movies, books, music etc, then I don't think there's anything that could cause alarm. If, however, the child has been brought up in some loony fundamentalist backwater, the sort of place where people suffered spontaneous explosive diarrhoea when Janet Jackson had her wardrobe malfunction, then he'll probably need deep and searching therapy for many years, especially after the bit with Tenpole Tudor in it.

Hope this helps.

reply

a simple yes would have sufficed.

reply

LOL...

reply

Wow. Even six and a half years later, this still reads like condescending art-school crap, written by somebody who is every bit as fundamentalist as the worst fundamentalist, in terms of projecting one value system as the true and pure one.

It'd be interesting to know whether this attitude has only hardened to the point of petrification, or whether you've learned to be somewhat more tolerant of other ideas of how to raise kids and what is appropriate for them at certain ages -- other ideas besides your own, I mean.

reply

The ending is a little steamy, but not explicit.

reply

[deleted]

I agree with the above poster: the violence is more intense than the steamy scenes.
There are a couple that are quite violent indeed, and there are scenes like men shaking the carriages with babies in them, etc.
And there is some rough language too.


She controlled the animals of the forest even the trees seeming to do her bidding.

reply

Why don't you watch it yourself first. How are a bunch of random strangers supposed to know what is suitable for your child?

"Rock is dead! Long live Paper and Scissors!"

reply

Absolutely Not. Unless you are one of those idiot, mindless, selfish parents these days that does not care what your kids get into for entertainment.

If you like subjecting your kids to:

- prostitues
- pimping
- w-hores
- alcoholism
- lots of N word racism
- white supremists
- disrepect
- lots of very violent fighting
- lots of hatred
- swearing

as forms of learning entertainment then by all means, jump in.

Otherwise, for god's sake man! Let them be KIDS until they are old enough to move out. They get enough premature maturing from regular radio and tv.
The movie is rated PG-13, not PG-8. And it is in 15 in other countries.

I know this post is years old, but goodness are modern parents REALLY this stupid? Why would someone even ask this?

reply

I wouldn't say any content here is unsuitable for a 9-year-old who enjoys "adult" films, but I would say that I can't imagine a 9-year-old who would understand or get much out of the film, and there probably aren't many who would enjoy it.

It's not necessarily easy for adults to follow the disjointed and often simply-intimated plot and character relationships, you really need to know something about England's history and culture to understand the film (for example, if you haven't the faintest idea what a "Ted" is, the film's not about to explain it to you, but there is plenty of content based on them being Teds), a major part of the story is about the "selling-out dilemma" (for artists and otherwise), another major part of the story requires some knowledge of (the history of) race relations, it takes some life-experience and analysis (again because things are not-so-directly stated) to understand the protagonist's dysfunctional family, some plot developments are relayed in song lyrics, and on and on.

In many ways Absolute Beginners is a "difficult viewing" film. It takes unbroken concentration and requires that viewers think a lot about what they're seeing.

But maybe some 9-year-olds would like the colorful visuals, the hyperkinetic approach and the music, and that's enough.


http://www.rateyourmusic.com/~JrnlofEddieDeezenStudies

reply