This isn't a musical!


Or is it? No lyrics were written specifically, every 'number' was mimed to the original recordings, just like Pennies from Heaven and Lipstick on your Collar

So don't be put off if you hate Chicago or West Side Story, The Singing Detective is on another planet!

reply

[deleted]

That's really bad because I like musicals. I loved West Side Story, Chicago so I'm really dissapointed in this.

I've watched half of the first part and I'm bored already.

reply

I feel the need to reinforce the point that this most definitely isn't what is generally understood as a "musical", though the music in it is important.

Still, it's the bestest mini-series of all time, so I'd have another go, if you did actually give up on it.

reply

It is a musical, among other things. Not an orthodox one, by any means, but it has musical numbers throughout - regardless that the songs aren't original and that they're lip synching to classics.

If I have to tell you again, we're gonna take it outside and I'm gonna show you what it's like!

reply