MovieChat Forums > Matlock (1986) Discussion > How Many Daughters Did Matlock Have?

How Many Daughters Did Matlock Have?


I've noticed three different actresses portraying a daughter of his, and all three characters have different names. However, I've never heard anything said in the series about how many daughters he has. So, do we just accept that he had three daughters, or that each time a new actress portrayed her we were then supposed to forget there were others?

Could be I'm analyzing it too much, but let me think about it.

reply

Good Morning!!

Hi!! .. Some time ago I had wondered the same... It seemed confusing, (maybe I over analyzed it as well ..lol)
...
After seeing your question I thought I'd go do some research ... I found the following answer from a Chicago Tribune posted many years ago ..

"You're right, three ladies have played the attorney's daughter ... and the first, Lori Lethin, was seen only in the show's pilot film. Purl then took over the part of Charlene once the weekly version began, but she left after the first season and was replaced by Nancy Stafford; the latter actress portrayed Matlock's associate, not his daughter. When the program switched from NBC to ABC, "One Life to Live" alumna Brynn Thayer
came aboard as a different Matlock daughter, Leanne;
I also checked in Wikipedia .. Seemed to be the same info ...
Hope you have an awesome day!
Cali

reply

Thanks so much for that info. It's too bad TV shows from back then often provided little continuity from one season to the next when it came to secondary characters. I think it would have been quite alright if they'd simply stated at some point that Matlock had three or four daughters ("four" in case the series had stayed on longer and another daughter stepped in).

reply

No bad mouthing here please. Once on the Cosby show Claire I believe remarked "why do we have four children?" I think Cliff replied "because we did not want five!" Eventually they did have five.

reply

Cliff and Claire always had 5 children. From oldest to youngest they were Sondra, Denise, Theo, Vanessa, and Rudy. Sondra didn't physically show up until later in the series, but she existed and was regularly mentioned prior to that. The other 4 were present starting with the pilot.

reply

Sherrywestburg is right..I remember that line of dialogue precisely !

reply

Yeah, sherry is right. The cosby show explicitly alleged that they only had 4 children, well before they later fabricated Sondra.

And cosby himself is also full of crap because in interviews long after the show ended, he claimed that he gave Theo a dyslexia story arc that can be seen running throughout the series, starting with the first episode. In reality, no, he didn't do anything even close to that. The first episode claims merely that Theo got bad grades because he was lazy, not because he had dyslexia. And the episodes that follow do not address dyslexia ~95%+ of the time. A couple of them do many years later...but certainly nowhere near enough to make it a story arc that runs throughout the series.

reply

8 kanillion

reply

Linda Purl played Charlene, and Brynn Thayer played Leanne...and they BOTH were lawyers

reply

I remember someone pointing out that Lorne Greene's sons all had different mothers on "The Big Bonanza." All his wives died since he was portrayed as a widower.

They said any woman he looked at should run away since all his wives died after giving birth to one of his sons.



I don't know everything. Neither does anyone else

reply

It's really not that big of a stretch on the Bonanza issue, lots of women died giving birth back then, and at least one could have died from illness or accident.

reply

To chicago85 ~ the correct title of Lorne Greene's TV series is "Bonanza", plain and simple.

reply

Well, I suppose that these programs do tend to become a bit Soapish every now and again. But doesn't Ben mention something to his Linda Purl daughter about her elder sister, who's away at Law School, during Linda's season?

Where else besides "Bonanza" does this happen? Yes, that Ben does mention Hoss' mother as different from Adam and Little Joe's, which could easily mean that they've had three different mothers.

But then anytime one of the Cartwright men romance a potential fiancee, she certain is lucky to escape from the Ponderosa alive and very fortunate because just try to begin to count the trail of murdered fiancees which those four amass.

Ricard Mulligan's character has two daughters on that one show set in Miami, or is it three? Carol and Barbara or Carol and Barbara and Emily or one comes after the other leaves.

Meanwhile, back on "Happy Days," the Cunninghams lose son Chuck, who suddenly disappears once he dribbles his basketball up the steps and never returns for dinner.

Alexis and Blake Carrington have four children, who are all kidnapped at one point in their lives. Adam, as a baby, is discovered as an adult in Montana. Fallon keeps disappearing for long spells even after she is cleverly portrayed by a different actress, who also disappears for a long time. Stephen is believed to be deceased for a long time after his stowaway ship explodes off the coast of Sumatra. And Amanda suddenly appears as an adult after Blake had no idea that she was ever a child. But you never see these four or five together in any one scene.

Even back in the day of "My Three Sons," one son disappears and is suddenly substituted by an adoptive son. "Donna Reed Show" exits a daughter before another suddenly appears. "Petticoat Junction" retains three daughters, but many cast changes appear along the way. "Doris Day Show" sons suddenly disappear without any trace. "Barnaby Jones" loses a son to murder in the first episode, but gains a daughter-in-law and a nephew to help him out of retirement.

So, apart from Soap Operas, who knows which series holds the record for introducing new family additions outside of childbirth? But "Matlock" certainly does its fair share, while Mrs. "Murder, She Wrote" gains an entire flock of long-lost nieces and nephews along the course, and she has to defend most of them, as well as her long-lost dear old friends because they're all often accused of murder, and she very often finds the bodies, as well.

But, unlike Ben Matlock, who charges that very, very steep $10,000 to prove his court case clients not guilty, Jessica Fletcher does it all backwards, amateurishly, and without any fee.

If Sheridan were here, he'd be appalled.

reply

Well, they didn't all die in childbirth....Adam's mother was the daughter of a Boston Seaman, and died in childbirth....Hoss's mother was Swedish and was killed by an Indian's arrow while traveling to Nevada in a wagon train when Hoss was still a baby....and Little Joe's mother was French Creole in New Orleans and lived till Joe was about 5 years old, then was murdered. There was a back flash episode to show each of these stories. The episodes explained why the three sons were all so different, in looks and in culture. For example, Hoss is the only one who says things like " Dang Burn It ! ", while Adam 's speech is so educated and cultured.

reply

I never felt comfortable with Brynn Thayer as Matlock's daughter as she had played a murderer in a previous episode!It seemed an odd choice.Was she a friend of his?

reply

I know exactly what you mean, JP, I RECENTLY saw the murderer episode, and recognizing her was creepy !

She might not be a relative or friend of Andy's, but maybe the Producer or Director.....a while back, I was watching an old episode of a TV Western, and there was a kid guest starring, who was the ugliest kid I ever saw. I thought to myself he MUST be related to someone, because certainly they did not audition hundreds of kids and chose this one ! Well, I anxiously waited for the credits to role to see who this kid was...and sure enough, he was Teddy Rooney, SON OF MICKEY ! !

reply

Also, the guy that played Cliff in the last 2 seasons (I think) was on the show a bunch before that roll. He played a doctor, a lawyer in New York. I guess using actors over and over was a thing back then. ??

reply

The answer is that he had ONE daughter. The original daughter Charlene Matlock (first played by Lori Lethin and then played by Linda Purl) simply morphed into Leanne McIntyre played by Brynn Thayer. So far as I know, it was never mentioned that he had more than one child. This is not uncommon in TV.

Apparently this is done deliberately by TV producers so that people will have something to talk about on message boards. If only they had known IMDb would someday shut them down...

reply

He had 14 with 8 different women. Lawyers in suspenders get tail like crazy.

reply