Hoping to put the whole 'questioning of the Sleaze Brothers' to rest
Since someone on here keeps going onto other threads and asking questions about the Sleaze Brothers (I will not name names), I thought I'd try and clarify some things, and give this topic it's own thread.
1) Why did both Sleaze brothers go to jail, when it was only Sam who stole the apple?
When they are pulled over by the trooper at the end, he reads them a list of things that the two have done:
Sam Sleaze: What seems to be the problem, officer? Whats the charge?
State Trooper: [looks through his notebook] What about counterfeiting, extortion, fraud, impersonating a dentist, stealing an apple from a kid?
As we can see from these quotes, there have been quite a few charges racked up than just stealing that kid's apple. Though keep in mind that whether they both went to jail is left to speculation.
2) How come the state trooper would not give up looking for the two Sleaze brothers? Why didn't he just go to the fun fair, where the boy had his apple stolen?
The brothers had already moved on from their previous set-up, before they arrived in the city of Toadstool. My assumption was the boy felt wronged, and like any kid is told (well, in our day in the 80's), reported wrongdoing to the Police. Plus, considering they also overcharged him for the Ferris Wheel (Sam demanded 10 cents for the kid to be let down), I probably would have reported this to the Police as well. And of course, by the time they went back to the fun fair, it was packed up and gone.
As to how the trooper and the boy managed to catch them, maybe an APB (all points bulletin) was put out on the men, and someone driving through Toadstool called the troopers). The trooper, most likely wanting the little boy to know that justice was done, offered to bring him along.
Though in terms of movie-logic, once Big Bird had been found by his friends, the movie still needed to get the bad guys (or bad guy, if you decide to not include Sid).
3) Did the Sleaze Brothers' truck get impounded?
It's most likely that it was-keeps them fro trying to make a getaway. Then again, they don't have a vehicle that could blend in that well with its surroundings.
4) Do you think that Sam could have spent longer in prison than Sid? Is it possible that Sid might have been let out early for good behaviour?
This enters into the realm of 'what if,' since the last we see of the two men is Sid Crying, and Sam looking to try and talk his way out of the situation.
It is entirely possible that a judge could have seen that Sid was an accomplice in Sam's schemes, and given his a shorter sentence or let him off.
Of course, Sam could also have been one of those guys that wouldn't go down alone if he was tried. One could almost imagine him bullying Sid to not say anything incriminating about him on the witness stand. Sam seemed a big enough jerk to pull that stunt.
5)What happened if Sid got bullied in prison? Would Sam have stood up for his younger brother?
Sam didn't seem like the kind really to show pity. He's the rougher of the two, and Sid is moreso the guy with the heart, albeit kind of the lapdog of the two. Sam would probably have been like, 'aw, tough it out, Sid.'
"Ridiculous Lucky Captain Rabbit King! Lucky Captain Rabbit King nuggets are for the youth!"