Ingemar's Disasters


The first couple of times I watched My Life As A Dog, I was taken by the "disasters" that seemd to accompany Ingemar as he moved through life. I am not speaking of the tragedy of losing his mother and his primary "family", but the disasters of spilling things, setting the dump on fire, getting "stuck" in the pop bottle, wetting the bed, etc. And certainly all of the commotion around Ingemar tooks its toll on his mother.

These "disasters" seem to disappear when he goes to live with his aunt and uncle, my memory was that it must have been because he no longer had to be the "perfect son" he wanted to be to help his mother get better.

But after my last viewing I've come to see him a bit differently. With the exception of the fire in the dump, virtually all of those other disasters were really instigated by his older brother. The pop bottle incedent, the wetting of the bed, spilling the batter, etc. His brother was always playing with his mind and Ingemar ran into problems when he tried to defend himself or Sicka.

In the end, I feel good about Ingemar and the prospects for his future. Once he is able to accept his new community and his new "family", it seems to me that he will have the freedom to grow and develop as he wants to. No longer will the "older brother" be stunting his growth and he is surrounded by people that genuinely care about him. Certainly his mother did, but she was pre-occupied by her illness and left to fend for herself by an absentee husband.

My vision for Ingemar is a better future where he can fully be himself.




Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

reply

Jamo!

My vision for Ingemar is a better future where he can fully be himself.


Absolutely!!
When the film ends it is June 26, 1959 and Sweden just got its first (and only?) heavy weight world champion: Ingemar (!) Johansson! All “normal” Swedes (count me out) went totally hysterical about this moronic and senseless so-called “victory”. (I was 19 at the time; a student in a military school of photography/cinematography, and I still remember how I felt deeply ashamed for being akin to my screaming and totally out of control mates at the school).

And what are our lovely kids Ingemar and Saga doing when everyone else in Sweden is hysterically glued to their radios? They are sleeping!

Once more: *Sleeeeping*!!!

The former aggressive, boxing, child heroin Saga is now peacefully sleeping in Ingemar’s arms, while the rest of Sweden is insanely berserking about some overweight Swedish boxer hitting the wits (if any) out of Floyd Patterson (Barf)!

To me this is such a lovely happy ending. I’m seriously planning to get a screen dump of that image (Saga and Ingmar peacefully sleeping together) and use it as wallpaper in my main net comp. To constantly remind me of good hope and better times.

So how can we now get Zam to feel a little happier about this film Jamo?? Any ideas?



cine
"Why is it that men are so much more interested in women than women in men?"
Virginia Woolf

reply

Hi Cine!

So how can we now get Zam to feel a little happier about this film Jamo?? Any ideas?

I think she should just rent it again and spend more time with it. For me, this past viewing was my third and unexpectedly I really focused on the scene where the entire town runs out to the river to witness the crazy neighbor (Fransson) going for his mid-winter swim. What really caught me this time was the look on Ingemar's face as he looks at Saga laughing along with the rest of the town at Fransson. At that point in time Ingemar comes to peace with his lot in life and embraces his new family and community. And he does so from a good place inside of himself.

Which leads to that wonderful scene of him and Saga asleep on the couch. I doubt he ever felt that much peace and security with his brother lurking around the corner, ready to terrorize him. So perhaps Zam should give it another try.



Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

reply

To me this is such a lovely happy ending. I’m seriously planning to get a screen dump of that image (Saga and Ingmar peacefully sleeping together) and use it as wallpaper in my main net comp. To constantly remind me of good hope and better times.
It is probably my all time favorite movie ending. You just know that everything is going to be okay from now on. What a warm fuzzy!

PS If you do get a screen dump, I would love a copy for wallpaper also. Thanks!



Are you going to pull those pistols or whistle "Dixie"?

reply

....if you want the story to end on a positive note ;)

both the film and the book are great!

reply

Yeah, I've heard that about the book. Still, do you recommend it?



Are you going to pull those pistols or whistle "Dixie"?

reply

yes! the book is just as good if not better than the movie. there are some differences though. trust me you will enjoy it

reply


Thanks, I look forward to it!


Are you going to pull those pistols or whistle "Dixie"?

reply

yep. a great ending.



Season's Greetings!

reply

Hi Cine!

One thing that has been on my mind about the story as depicted in the movie since my last viewing is that Ingemar gains a "father" in the course of the story. I think an easily overlooked scene, yet one that is quite poignant and touching, is the scene where Ingemar is defending his father to his little female friend in his home town. It's the scene where she is questioning why his father is off in another part of the world instead of being home helping his mother raise the family.

But Ingemar hides his hurt by defending his father and the important work he is doing. Certainly Ingemar and his brother are willing to sacrifice a relationship with their father knowing that the world's banana supply is being kept safe and in tact by the heroic efforts of his father in loading the bananas!!! That scene rings as authentic to me from the standpoint that children often mask their feelings of loneliness or abandonment by defending their parents' shortcomings and building up the improtance of whatever supplants them in their parent's eyes. At young ages, children look at their parents as gods who must know what is best in all circumstances.

I find it very interesting and effective in the storytelling that Ingemar builds a relationship with his uncle after he leaves home. In fact, Lasse Hallstrom (and perhaps the book's author as I have not read the book) make a very interesting and smart decision by having the aunt's character be a smaller, more minor character in the story. When Ingemar's mother dies (who Ingemar is most close to), she is not replaced in any way by another woman or surrogate mother. But Ingemar has already begun to develop a strong relationship with his uncle.

Ultimately Ingemar gains a father-figure by the end of the story which was a void that already existed in Ingemar's life before losing his mother. And mother is not diminished or trivialized by a superficial replacement of another woman. The whole transition flows very smoothly and in a touching way. The look on Ingemar's uncle's face while listening to his sobs is another easily overlooked point in the movie.

You know the more I watch and consider this movie, the more it grows on me!



Once in a while you get shown the light, in the strangest of places if you look at it right.

reply

Hi Jamo

Yes, of course!!! Ingemar wins a ”father” and loses a mother! I feel like for not realizing it before. But lappri with pride! The really important thing is that I, thanks to you, now can see this very important aspect of the drama. I have to watch it again with this new dimension to it.

Your analysis opens up a really complex structure: Father/maleness/aggression versus Mother/femaleness/caring. How do aggressive, boxing young *woman* Saga fit in, in this puzzle? Now the beautiful end scene (Saga and Ingemar peacefully sleeping together, while the rest of Sweden was hysterically focused on rude and vulgar aggression) takes on a new and much more complicated meaning.

And, yes I agree, this film grows with each new viewing. Your analysis adds a lot the already rich drama. I’ll be back on this toopic as soon as I can.

All the best

cine

"Why is it that men are so much more interested in women than women in men?"
Virginia Woolf

reply