No wonder MST passed on the original!
Wow. I found the original Legend of Boggy Creek at my local Blockbuster. I rented it and had a VERY hard time watching it. It makes Boggy Creek II look like a Spielberg film. I could only sit through about 20 minutes at a time. First of all, it's a terrible film-to-video transfer and it's kinda squished sideways to fit on a TV screen. The sound, the acting, the music... all terrible. Although, we are treated to a really bad song... a couple times, in fact. Oh, and we get to see the actor who played the storekeeper in the sequel in his younger, thinner, clean-shaven, sweat-stain-free glory! But, really, the biggest problem is the interminable stretches of sound-free footage -- no dialogue, no music, very little sound effects work. And it's really dark, so there's not much to look at, either. I thought "Manos": The Hands of Fate and The Touch of Satan were heavy on the pauses, but they've got nothing on this movie. I doubt even the MST people would be able to save this one. There's simply nothing to react to! If you manage to find it, watch it with extreme caution. It's rough.
***The thing we're looking for is coming! Oh, NO!***