MovieChat Forums > Robotech (1985) Discussion > What Did Rick Hunter and the SDF-3's Mis...

What Did Rick Hunter and the SDF-3's Mission Take So Long?


OK, at the end of the Macross Saga, Rick Hunter and Lisa Hayes take the SDF-3 into deep space to try and contact the Robotech Masters to form a peace between their peoples, right?


OK, from what I've read, it was 22 years before they completed their mission and somewhere along the way they came across the Heydanites and received "Shadow Technology"


I've never come across an explanation as why it took Rick Hunter so long to complete the mission, if in fact he did at all? What happened along the way to hold them up?

reply

Well, among other things, they got caught up in a war with the Regent's half of the Invid. Apparently after freeing Tirol, the REF were basically devoting their full resources to liberating more than half-a-dozen planets belonging to the Sentinels, as well as dealing with Edwards' inner treachery, and did I mention battling the Regent's equivalent of what the Regess brought to Earth (which was more than enough to take it over). Other factors would've been waiting for a new Protoculture Matrix to be constructed for the SDF-3, setting up Space Station Liberty for contact with Earth, and building colonies on Mars and around Jupiter presumably to keep portions of the human race scattered to avoid complete extinction.

Then you have to take into account that the REF did send troops back to Earth at a few points between the Second and Third Robotech Wars, including Major Carpenter's battle-fortress in 2029, the offscreen Jonathan Wolfe's forces around June 2030 (which evidently included Lunk and the old geezer vets from later in New Generation), Lancer's 10th Mars Division in 2038, and Scott's 21st Mars Division in 2042. Keep in mind also, apparently the SDF-3 had some distant involvement in Scott's fleet offensive, as the SDF-3 ("Admiral Hunter's flagship") was giving the key order to attack. 2042 is also probably around the time Prelude Chapter 1 began, with Edwards killing Lynn Kyle, as the term "decades" is emphasized since the Pioneer Mission began.

In the end, it's mostly left up to viewer assumptions and small stuff like what Carpenter tells Leonard in "Outsiders". We got roughly 20 years of offscreen mystery which hasn't and may never be answered, that's about all the in-universe explaining I can think of in regards to the story. For a more obvious and blunt explanation...

It's because Robotech, as brilliant as the interweaved story is, was made up of three different animated shows and thus new casts of characters had to be come up with for each following saga. This is why, aside from the key exception of the Sentinels movie (which was American produceD), we never see Rick Hunter again until the Prelude comics and Shadow Chronicles movie. The writers were clever enough in other character points, like making the main character of The Masters Dana Sterling (which even allowed a cameo instance, even if vague and very brief, of her parents in that arc's last ep), but it seems the best that could be done with Rick was his status as a prominent offscreen character in The New Generation.

I hope I was able to answer some of your questions.

Any Buffyverse comic that's post-"Not Fade Away" is non-canon, my PoV says. Denny Crane!

reply

Robotech: The Shadow Chronicles is the first original Robotech animation, unless you count Robotech II: The Sentinels. Of course Harmony Gold could have recycled Macross footage with Hikaru Ichijo in Southern Cross and Mospeada but that would have been trickier.

reply

Robotech: The Shadow Chronicles is the first original Robotech animation, unless you count Robotech II: The Sentinels.


Which I do. Ignoring how its pilot-like setup is due to it being an aborted series, the Sentinels movie is more-so an original American production for the Robotech continuity which comes off decently as a 'direct-to-video' project. We get a character-centered piece around Earth that bridges the gap between The Macross Saga and The Masters, at the same time an action oriented plot on the Robotech Masters' homeworld which foreshadows why the REF will be so busy, all while allowing us to see characters from all three arcs and a glimpse at the threat continually referenced in The Masters. The Sentinels feature also hasn't really contradicted anything as shown in Shadow Chronicles or Prelude, unlike the novels and comics, as the movie only goes up to just before the Pioneer fleet leaves Earth while Prelude's prologue begins as it arrived at Tirol.

The thing with why the Sentinels feature gets largely ignored is mostly because of its obscure release record, as well as the well known fact that it was just "pilot material" for other stuff that never came about. To be honest, I love the Sentinels movie; we get a more real bridging between Macross and Masters that "Dana's Story" just doesn't quite serve up to snuff on its own, the rare treat of seeing varying characters from all three arcs (granted, only the Regess and Jonathan Wolfe appeared on behalf of The New Generation), and of course the beautiful wedding between Rick Hunater and Lisa Hayes. In my eyes, it serves as a perfect epilogue to the stories of the surviving Macross Saga characters before their departure, as well as a fantastic bridging piece to further elements of the series (including Prelude & Shadow Chronicles).

Any Buffyverse comic that's post-"Not Fade Away" is non-canon, my PoV says. Denny Crane!

reply

It's a shame they couldn't continue with the Sentinels plan as intended; as uneven as the feature may be it featured some truly chilling off world war material and showed a lot of promise. And yeah, the wedding scene itself was executed very well.

reply