Why did Tom hit Ellen?


On the bus, why did he do that? Tom and Ellen obviously love each other.

reply

To stop her from wanting to follow him when he went to confront Raven.
________________
there will be snark

reply


I don't think it was meant maliciously at all. It was more like for her own protection, just to keep her out of (worse) harm's way. Maybe a hypodermic sedative injection would have been better, or more "elegant," but Cody didn't have anything like that available, even if he knew how to use it.

Ozy

And I stood where I did be; for there was no more use to run; And again I lookt with my hope gone.

reply

It's a convention of movies that if you punch somebody the right way, you can knock them out for a few hours with no ill effects. In real life, a concussion that renders you unconscious for more than a few seconds is a good reason to go the hospital.

"The truth 24 times a second."

reply


Regrettably, this is very true. A concussion sufficient to knock someone unconscious (even briefly) is no small thing, in Real Life. In fact, it is not uncommonly fatal. :o(

Ozy

And I stood where I did be; for there was no more use to run; And again I lookt with my hope gone.

reply

I heard of a guy who was riding his bike down the road, a truck bouncy along, bounced off an piece of iron, hitting the cyclist in the head, he NEVER woke up.

reply

It was clearly for her protection and to avoid the argument she'd almost certainly make to either stop him or go with him. He didn't have the time.

However, a hypodermic with a sedative is equally dangerous to a knockout concussion. Without knowing someone's weight and medical history, any sedative can kill or cuase serious damage. Anesthesiology is a medical specialty because of this.

reply

of course the best way to render someone unconscious in the absence of a sedative is to hit them smartly on the back of the neck/shoulderblades whilst shouting "Judo Chop!!"

reply

Ha ha, seriously though it's common practice to punch women squarely in the face for their own protection.

reply

God Damn! That 's funny!

reply

For the same reason Joe Sullivan hit Polly in "Sky Captain".

"They sucked his brains out!"

reply


Because she was giving him lip, and he was having none of it.

reply

Exactly.

reply

Definitely seemed a little excessive given what he was trying to accomplish, but yes, he clearly punched her and knocked her out for her own protection (ironically) to keep her from coming after him. If he was really incapable of convincing her to stay put or go somewhere safe, he could've simply tied her hands or something to that effect. Can't imagine cold cocking someone that I love as much as he claimed to have loved her, it seemed a little odd.

reply

He was, basically, quite a dick in many respects.

reply

Ironically, to protect her.

reply