MovieChat Forums > A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984) Discussion > Suppose Jordan Peele decided to make a B...

Suppose Jordan Peele decided to make a Black-cast reboot of this...


Would he cast a Black actor as Freddie Krueger or keep him as a White man seeing as Freddie is an evil molester/killer and all? Personally, I think Morgan Freeman could be an excellent Freddie Krueger.

reply

Morgan Freeman is too old for the role. Though he has played Bad guy roles like Street Smart. Donad Glover as Lieutanant Thompson.

reply

You wouldn't see his age with the prosthetics/make-up on. Robert Englund could have be 20 or 60 under all that stuff.

reply

That's not what I meant. I meant he is way too old to endure having such a ton of make up put on his face and hands. I doubt he'd want to. He's over 80 years old now.

reply

Lance Reddick

reply

DENZEL AS FREDDY...AMAZING!

reply

"keep him as a White man seeing as Freddie is an evil molester/killer and all?" Are you kidding me?

reply

Well, it IS Jordan Peele...

reply

Kanye West

reply

Seeing as his skin is burnt away it doesn't really matter what colour he is.

reply

Freddy used to be human, and the movies showed him from before he was burnt, so it kinda does matter.

reply

Only matters if skin colour matters to you.

reply

Accuracy to the source material matters to me, which can include skin color if that’s one of the things they changed.

reply

What in the source material says to you that skin colour is important for any of the characters? This isn't a challenge or anything, it's just curiosity.

reply

It’s more about the overall design. If they look a certain way, and act a certain way, I’d prefer they keep them that way.

If I grew up with a character, and I’ve gotten attached to how that character is, I want that character to remain intact as much as possible. Some changes are inevitable, but keep them minimal. This especially applies if the character is based on a real person, and/or someone rooted in culture, mythology, and ethnicity.

reply

So I'm guessing you hated the remake?

reply

I didn’t hate it, but it still wasn’t that good overall. I enjoyed the Friday the 13th remake a lot more.

I’m not as… “concerned” or “passionate”, for lack of a better word, when it comes to slasher movies, but I may still bring it up on principle.

reply

The actual colour of Freddy is irreverent to who he becomes once burned and killed so doesn't really matter what colour a potential remake makes him surely?

reply

Well, if it was the other way around, and Freddy was originally a black guy and they cast a white actor in the remake, do you think people would just accept it? Even if you told them “his face is burnt so it doesn’t really matter”?

Or what if it was an original black character like Candyman? His skin color technically doesn’t matter, so they could get a white guy in a remake, do you think people would just accept that?

reply

When you think of Freddy you think of the burnt creepy looking fella not what he looked like before or his colour.

reply

Depends on who “you” are. Are you a fan who wants to respect the source material? Are you a Hollywood producer who wants to fill a quota? Or are you a casual who’s easily entertained by anything?

Robert Englund, the original (white) actor who played him, also comes to mind for many people.

reply

Chris Tucker as Freddy Krueger all the way

reply

Well in that case, why not? 😄

reply

Shame the movie industry doesn't agree.

All they care about is skin colour

reply

Too bad Redd Foxx isn't available.

reply

Make him black, why not. As long as they can land the comedic jokes of Freddy I dont care. Hell...you know what? KEVIN HART as Freddy!!!!! Bring in Dwayne Johnson as Roland Kinkaid while were at it and you have a surefire hit!

reply