Jeffrey or O.J.

They are both dispicable and both should have gotten the death penalty in my opinion. However, I would say Jeffrey MacDonald is worse. Both killed people out of rage. However, when you have studied both cases closely, and I have, you see that O.J. was in a complete rage when he murdered Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman. More than likely O.J.only remembers the first few seconds of the actual murders and then his mind repressed the memory of the rest of the events that took place that night. It is ironic how the mind works and how the mind will repress memories like this in order to protect one's psyche. The mind protects the body.

Jeff is a slightly different creature. Jeff was also in a rage when he got into a fight with Colette the night of the murders. He broke both of her arms and knocked her unconscience, but she was still alive. Jeff killed Kimberly instantly when he crushed in the left side of her skull. She was standing in the doorway when the fight took place and her death was the result of a fatal blow to the head with a wooden club. Although Jeff was in a rage at the time of the fight, there was a point at which he came to his senses, so to speak. He realized that he killed his eldest daughter and his wife was near death. At that point he devised a plan to cover up the murders. It was at that point that he decided to finish off his wife and his youngest daughter, Kristen. That makes him, in my opinion, worse. Any man who can stab his 2-year-old daughter in the heart 33 times, with thrusts so forceful that they go through the body and into the bed mattress is much worse! He was not in a rage when he killed Kristen. He knew exactly what he was doing and he did it to save his own hide. How tragically sad and pathetic he is!

You can tell that Jeff knew what he was doing when he killed Kristen because he has a very difficult time discussing her death in interviews. If you have the opportunity to watch a Jeffrey MacDonald interview, do so and watch his mannerisms as he describes Kristen's death. His whole body language changes and his voice will crack and tremble when he speaks. When he speaks about Colette and Kimberly's death he does so as a doctor would describing the diagnosis of a patient. He is removed and detached when he speaks. However, Kristen is a different story. He killed her with malicious intent. He knows it and he remembers it. This is why it is difficult for him to speak about it.

The man is a cold blooded killer. He deserves to suffer the way he family suffered or worse. May he rot in hell!

Both are disgusting creatures, it's hard to choose, but I'll have to say macdonald, because of the children, even though o.j. left his wife, goldman for the children to find,I have to agree with ccap about kristin,I'll have to watch him more closely in interviews, even though I can't stand the sight of him!

[deleted]

Neither is worse. I would choose Paul Snider, the hustler and murderer of Dorothy Stranton. He was a "narcissistic sociopath" who seduced and later murdered a naive young woman for his own ambitions, and then committed suicide after raping her and murdering her with a shotgun... and then having sex with her dead body before killing himself with the same shotgun he used to kill her.

Eric Roberts portrayal of Snider in the film 'Star 80', is an equal on par with the character of Jeffery MacDonald who was portrayed by Gary Cole in 'Fatal Vision'. The only difference between MacDonald and O.J. Simpson is that Snider took the easy way out of committing suicide after killing Dorothy Stranton.