I think the biggest difference between the two (in my opinion) is that CtB had much better "battle" action especially when it came to the Riders of Doom both in the beginning and end. Most of the individual, one-on-one action was either very short (as you said) & chopped/edited (such as the pit fights) or felt a little too choreographed to me. The only real exception for me was the final showdown with Rexor as mentioned previously.
CtD on the other hand has much better personal and intimate fight scenes. The one scene you mentioned between Conan and the Queen's guard (played by his good friend, Sven Ole Thorsen... how many times has he been killed by Arnie? lol) is just absolutely top-notch. The ringing of steel, the speed and impact of their swords... it is truly an awesome fight. Even Conan and Bombaata versus the Keepers of the Horn had some great action; when Bombaata picks up that scrawny dude by the neck and lifts him two feet off the ground, I always laugh at just what that guy was thinking! I can't help but enjoy the light-hearted approach this film took and the way it made you want to cheer almost during the fight scenes.
The notable exception is of course Toth-Amon controlling the "Ape-Man" creature. The professional wrestling and almost cartoonish feeling of this fight is just ridiculous for me. I will say though that 9 times out of 10, it is better to have a real object there with with to interact. A "real" Dagoth to slash at and as in CtB, an actual snake prop for Conan to hack the head off. The days before CGI became a crutch almost.
reply
share