Why is it rated R? - Birdy (1984) Discussion

[–] josephforooghian 18 years ago

There is a scene of sex between the main character and Al (Nicholas Cage) it is a gay side-plotline. Plus someone ejaculates into a cup.

reply

[–] 18 years ago

[deleted]

[–] heelmaster2000 18 years ago

How is the violence, I am just asking beacause it is set in Vietnam and it is a war movie at times so what is it like?

The MPAA just a buch of wacko's in buisness suits.

reply

[–] griemanhilda 14 years ago

Before i saw it a also thoughtit was a war movie but actually it's not there's like 5 minutes or less of Vietnam war in the whole movie and you can see that by the end.

reply

[–] Razzbar 9 years ago

It's not set in Vietnam. There are a few minutes of intensely violent war action, but most of the movie takes place in a hospital mental ward, and in flashbacks to their teenage years before joining the Army.

It definitely IS a "war movie", because it's about the *effect* of war on two soldiers who were best friends before the war, and what the war did to them.

It's something like "The Deer Hunter" in structure. Who they were before, during, and after. The "during" part of this movie is very short, but very bloody.

reply

[–] fireant3 17 years ago

This guy's full of crap; there's no gay stuff like that at all. I'd say it's probably the scene where Nic Cage is doing the chick while Birdy is nearby being lame not conversing well with his date. There's no nudity in that scene but it's still fairly graphic or was to the MPAA in 1984.

reply

[–] mikemorton 18 years ago

Possibly because of the masturbation scene - when Birdy gets off on thinking he's a bird

reply

[–] 18 years ago

[deleted]

[–] the_fisher_king 17 years ago

First of all there is no gay content in this movie AT ALL, the person who said that there is a gay sex scene was talking sh*t. Anyway, there is some nudity in the movie, and few scenes of sexuality, there is some very brief violence and a scene including a lot of references to violence against dogs. I think that mainly it. See it, it's an amazing movie.

"The life is a scene badly written in which we must play"

reply

[–] fiveginst1 17 years ago

There's also a scene of nudity from Maud Winchester while she's in a car with Birdy. Although that wouldn't make it 'R' automatically, I guess the MPAA didn't like the fact that there is physical contact on her breasts from Birdy (he touches them with his hand). The scene isn't that long, and it's really innocent from what I remember of it.

reply

[–] heelmaster2000 15 years ago

Primarily it's rated R for Language, Nudity (breasts and make buttocks) and brief but still bloody scenes of war violence.

reply

[–] brucebowen 15 years ago

i am 12 and my dad dosent like me waching sex scenes so is there much ?

reply

[–] brucebowen 15 years ago

how long is the sex scene ?

reply

[–] lordasaki 14 years ago

It's rated R because they say "the F word" a whole lot. You only have to say it two or three times to get an R rating (it depends on the context though).

There's less boobs in this movie than a PG-13 flick, and I'm not sure that they actually do have sex, since they're wearing clothes. Lots of non-sexual manbutt though.

The violence is probably enough to warrant an R, and ratings or not, the scene with the dead animals (you'll know when you see) is quite hard to watch.

reply