MovieChat Forums > Beverly Hills Cop (1984) Discussion > ‘Cobra’ Would Have Been ‘Beverly Hills C...

‘Cobra’ Would Have Been ‘Beverly Hills Cop’ if Sylvester Stallone Had His Way


https://filmschoolrejects.com/cobra-beverly-hills-cop/

In Sly’s version of Beverly Hills Cop, the main character’s name was changed from Foley to Cobretti, and the comedy was replaced with action set-pieces and hard-edged violence. If Paramount pressed ahead with Stallone’s script, the film would have cost even more to make. Unable to see eye to eye with their star, the producers replaced him with Murphy. The decision to ditch Stallone paid off too, as Beverly Hills Cop was a huge hit.

Afterward, Stallone repurposed his Beverly Hills Cop ideas and Cobra was born. The Cannon Group — which was probably the only studio that would happily give Stallone $25 million to make a violent vanity project — stepped up to the plate and supported his vision. George P. Cosmatos was hired to direct the film, but it’s believed that Stallone was the real captain of the ship. Of course, that rumor is hardly surprising considering that Stallone has a history of overseeing his own projects. Whoever really helmed Cobra did a great job.

Upon release, Cobra was a box office hit, grossing $160 million worldwide. And while the film’s critical lampooning and subsequent Razzie Award nominations effectively killed any interest in a sequel right away, a ZX Spectrum game was released to coincide with the film. The game bears little resemblance to the movie, but it’s a fun little romp all the same. However, if you want to see a movie that exists because of Cobra, I highly recommend Black Cobra starring Fred Williamson. Unlike Stallone’s gem, Black Cobra spawned three sequels.

Still, it’s a shame that Stallone’s renegade detective didn’t receive further cinematic outings. Cobretti is a great action hero, and Stallone is clearly a fan of the character. Rocky Balboa and John Rambo are his golden geese, but Cobretti was the hero with franchise potential that got away. I’m sure he has no regrets about turning down Beverly Hills Cop, though — the actor is still kicking ass to this day. Furthermore, Stallone being fired from the other ’80s classic led to two great movies being made as a result. In the end, fans of action cinema were spoiled.

reply

I think like BH Cop 2 and 3 were what they had in mind if Stallone signed up as they are based a lot more on action than comedy.

reply

I actually think that could have been pretty good.

reply

Sly was interviewed for a book called Powerhouse where he said: "I took the script, and I rewrote it as a kind of compromise, where the guy was action-oriented, but he also had a wry sense of humor and was comedically sarcastic. Well, they didn't like that at all."

His agent, Ron Meyer, is quoted in the book as saying: “Nobody wanted his version, so I begged him Please, do the original script. This is a movie that's going to be a hit. Someone else is going to do it and you're going to regret it. Please, please, please do this movie. It turned into such a big fight that I was on the phone screaming at him Don't be stupid. In the end, he said If you mention it again, I'm going to fire you. Then Barry Diller said We can replace him. Years later, Sly was feeling bad about something and I wanted him to feel better, so I said I should have fought harder for you to do Beverly Hills Cop. He said You're right. You should have. There's no moral here; it's just a long story with no punch line.”

reply

It would have failed with Stallone even if he stuck to the original script.

reply

Beverly Hills Cop 2 was more action filled and makes me think it's the screenplay from the Stallone version. What made the film unique was the fast talking funny cop.

reply