MovieChat Forums > Charles in Charge (1984) Discussion > Who's prettier, Nicole or Josie???

Who's prettier, Nicole or Josie???


Nicole was obviously the pretty one on C.I.C. Her character was supposed to be the teen pinup/bombshell. But in real life, Josie Davis is way prettier then her. If you compare pictures of both of them now, Josie makes Nicole look kinda homely. What do you guys think?

reply

Josie looks real hot now so I pick her.

reply

I always had a thing for Lila Pembroke.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

nicole

reply

[deleted]

Josie

reply

Me too! I can agree with that as well ThatsFutureman! I always thought she was hot! Did you see her last movie she ever did? WOW! From Lila Pembrook to the woman she became she was very beautiful! I think her body and beauty was better than Nicole and Josie I hate to say it.

reply

Yeah Lila

reply

I really like Lila

reply

the nutjob who liked horses ? i liked april herman/haney too.

reply

Then, Josie.
Now, it's a tossup. Maybe still Josie.
I liked Nicole better presurgery definitely.

THERE IS SUCH A THING AS THE *ENTER* KEY!

-----------------------------------------------------
Look behind you! A THREE-headed monkey!!!!!!

reply

Well, during the show? Nicole was prettier. They fixed Jamie up more and made her wear more stylish clothes. But they're older now. Nicole has aged, Josie is prettier at the moment I think. When I saw her on E True Hollywood for Charles in Charge, I thought she was so pretty, she doesn't look at all like the conservative Josie on the show who played Sarah.

=O)

reply

Josie Davis was very pretty then and she is very pretty now. Nicole now looks so different than she did in her CIC years. I guess single motherhood really took her toll.

reply

I would have to say during the show it was Nicole Eggert but after the show finished and I saw Josie Davis in other roles. WOW! She became very beautiful! I have seen Nicole on TV from time to time and she is still beautiful but I would have to go with now Josie. As I said in a posting on here I even liked Lila Pembrook. She was beautiful when she was on there the first season of the show. I somewhat wonder if they had kept the Pembrooks what she would have looked like growing up as a teen from 1984 to 1990. What do you guys think?

reply

Nicole was better looking then and Josie is better looking now. Age has been kind to Josie! Wow..

reply

I have to agree with you on that back in the mid 80's that Nicole looked better than Josie but I would have to say now Josie looks better now than Nicole does.

Dedicated to USA UP ALL NIGHT and the fans of the show! http://usa-uan.deefilmroll.com/

reply

[deleted]

Nicole is one of the prettiest women I've ever seen. Back then she was gorgeous, but now I think Josie looks better. Both are very attractive though.

reply

[deleted]

I agree with you--Josie is much prettier now, whereas Nicole has lost that "glam" look that she had on C.I.C. She is still attractive though, but like you said, she looks plain now in comparison to Josie.

reply

Nicole definitely. shes got the tan and everything. thats why even scott baio had to tap that.

reply

Ellen Travolta was the hottest!!!!...Either that or Rue McClanahan. WET DREAM!

reply

Definitely Lila. Better actress too.

reply

I always thought Josie was prettier than Nicole

The World Will Look Up And Shout "Save Us!" And I'll Whisper...Why So Serious?!

reply