MovieChat Forums > Silkwood (1984) Discussion > How many cigarrettes did Meryl Streep sm...

How many cigarrettes did Meryl Streep smoke in this film


just about every scene she was in she was puffing her head off!! Disgusting!



'left alone, in the dark, seeking out your lost soul.....'

reply

I know, it was relentless and quite annoying.

reply

Karen Silkwood was a smoker, so that's part of the character ! It's just the way it's suppose to be, ok ? I hate when people piss about stupid things.

reply

She lit up loads, but didn't finish one! And when Kurt leaves, he takes 2 cartons of cigs out of the kitchen cupboard. somebody was trying to make a smoking/cancer point...yawn!

reply

cigarette makes character look dark and someway handsome so people can keep their eyes on them.

reply

Look, it was the 70's EVERYBODY smoked

Nil Illegetti Desperadum

reply

It is a more accurate depiction of a smoker onscreen, for once. Far too often, a character will light up at an important moment in the film, take a few drags, and either stub it out or the director will cut away, and nowhere else in the film will we see the character smoking. This is a far more accurate depiction of a smoker... reminds me a lot of one of my friend's parents, that's just how accurate it is.

reply

[deleted]

It occurred to me since my last post here the complete irony of the original post: someone commented that they were shocked to see a person smoking onscreen, but never once expressed shock that a corporation deliberately irradiated one of its employees when she tried to reveal their unpleasant little secrets, and then forced her into a car "accident" to finish her off. I think someone missed the point of the film.

reply

I agree PorkPie007. It was a very realistic depiction of smokers. I used to smoke and just about everyone in my family has smoked or does smoke. It's a constant thing when you smoke, not just when you're in a certain mood.

In this day and age though it stands out A LOT in older movies.



reply

Excuse me. Will all you negative jerks quit attacking this poor poster? He merely stated a fact and his opinion on smoking which I agree with 100%! He didn't make any comments about people smoking or not smoking in the 70's so don't attack him for that. Furthermore I find it really disgusting that Karen Silkwood is so concerned about dying from Plutonium exposure when it's obvious she's probably going to get lung cancer a hell of a lot sooner!

reply

Her character was a smoker, get over it. The film took place in the 70's, long before it was PC to attack smokers and long before lung cancer became the epidemic it is today. And this coming from a non-smoker! If I see a character smoke in a movie, it doesn't make me want to run out and buy a pack of cigarettes. Calm down people.

reply

What a load of crap, nothing important to do?

reply

nicerobot, Your a idiot,and a young one at that. I know the original poster did not make any comments about smoking in the 70's. Someone was explaining to him why the character smoked in the movie. In the 70's,when this movie was supposed to take place,smoking was very common everywhere. Your too young to remember that though. And for your comment that you "find it really disgusting that Karen Silkwood is so concerned about dying from Plutonium exposure when it's obvious she's probably going to get lung cancer a hell of a lot sooner!", Cig companies could advertise and market back then without repercussions. Its not the same now days. Now they have to tell you about cancer,etc. Smoking was very common back in the 70's,you could smoke on planes,trains,smoke in the mall,movies even the hospital. Times were different back then,it was socially acceptable,that is why she smoked. So SHUT-UP about things you have NO knowledge about.

reply

To put this as simply as possible...

She only worked the plant about two years.

I'm guessing if she smoked as much as it showed her smoking, she had the addiction far over two years.

Smoking is voluntary.

Getting radioactive poison is not.

However, even with will power one cannot kick an addiction that strong easily.

BUT...one can easily with the amount of will power Karen had, try to eliminate harmful effects of working in the conditions she and her fellow employees were working in

reply

"Furthermore I find it really disgusting that Karen Silkwood is so concerned about dying from Plutonium exposure when it's obvious she's probably going to get lung cancer a hell of a lot sooner!"

Haha! I too thought that exact same thing. I saw the title to this thread and then looked up at the movie, which is on TV now, only to find Karen puffing away on another cigarette. Very amusing.

reply

So... how many cigarettes is she seen smoking in this film? Like, an actual number.

reply

78

reply

Please, get a life.

reply

I remember watching this movie and thinking "damn, they smoke a lot" hehehe

reply

The character's priorities shouldn't be the same as ours . . .

reply

Yeah, but it is funny though hehehe they were smoking cigarettes like every 5 minutes!

reply

Who Cares

reply

wow. u guys are actually getting emotionally invested in this rather harmless question...those who said "to get a life" should practice what u preach

reply

seriously if plutonium exposure did not kill her, the lung cancer from smoking would.


>> An armadillo could be a
better president than Bush. <<

reply

Drew says basically the same thing to Karen in the film. She was talking, I think, about Thelma being 'cooked' and the plutonium levels or something & he says "If you're so worried about cancer, stop smoking."
But it was set in the early 1970's. The surgeon general had issued warnings about smoking but smoking still wasn't seen as a serious threat yet. People weren't used to it yet the way they are today. So it makes sense that Karen would be worried about the nuclear issues regarding cancer & that of her co-workers, smokers & non-smokers alike mind you, than she would be about her own cigarette smoking.

reply

The one thing it did for me is that I had no sympathy for her health problems, which kind of killed all the dramatic tension that we are supposed to feel at the end of the film.


"My name is Paikea Apirana, and I come from a long line of chiefs stretching all the way back to the Whale Rider."

reply

Like 200. I'm wondering if the incessant smoking was meant to be ironic? Probably not. This was 1983. People didn't have sticks up their asses about smoking twenty four years ago like they do now.

A good traveller has no fixed plans, and is not intent on arriving.

reply

Meryl chain-smokes more convincingly than any other actor I can recall in this movie.

reply