MovieChat Forums > Silkwood (1984) Discussion > What was the company doing wrong?

What was the company doing wrong?


I've read the Silkwood wiki page, and the wiki page for Karen Silkwood, but, I didn't understand exactly what kerr-mcgee was doing wrong?

What was the company allegedly doing to the workers that made Karen speak out in the first place?



reply

Hi. Did you watch the movie?

__________
I'm the best at what I do, and what I do best isn't very nice.
I'm the Wolverine.

reply

I have...three times in two weeks actually which might make me sound even more stupid haha!

I just want to make sure I know exactly what they did wrong.

It seemed like Karen didn't take her job seriously until Thelma got "Cooked" and then she seemed to realise that they were working with dangerous material!

But what was the company doing wrong?
What was going on with the truck they were pulling apart that Karen was looking at before the security guard told her to go away?

Was the company purposely contaminating work areas to harm the workers? I just want to get the facts right that's all?

What made Karen want to join the union exactly?

What was the first thing that happened to really make Karen feel the work place wasn't safe?

The only thing I'm 100% sure about is that they were making and shipping off rods that were defected but hid the imperfections with a black pen!

Just wanna get the info right!

Also when Karen had to stay back to clean up the cake she spilt, how did she get contaminated? WAS she targeted by her boss's before she even joined the union simply because she was a trouble maker, always came to work late and didn't do her job well?

I'm sure once someone tells me it will make sense and I'll feel like a dickhead but for some reason its gone over my head!

reply

But what was the company doing wrong?


They were doing a government contract and were trying to maximize profit, so they cut some corners.

They were making fuel for a new reactor - each rod assembly is made up of a bunch of pellets normally jacketed in other metals (to avoid reaction with the water in the reactor at high temps).

Karen's crew were making the smallest part of the whole - which looked like sintered/pressed fuel pellets... made by compressing metal powder in a mold.

Plutonium dust isn't actually _as_ hazardous on the skin (in super tiny quantities) as they seem to show. Don't get me wrong, you never want plutonium dust on you, partially because it burns in air, but I'd take that over a drop of nerve gas any day.

Ingestion, on the other hand, is very nasty - since the plutonium is giving off a small but constant amount of ionizing radiation - that means that the particles it's shooting out can knock apart chemical compounds in your cells.

Do it enough times and the cell dies or goes cancerous. Or you kill off your bone marrow.

Inhaling radioactive powder will of course have some serious lung concerns - swallowing would be the entire throat and digestive tract. Plus it behaves as a heavy metal, so there can be toxicity issues alongside the radiation.

The plutonium will create more radiation the more plutonium is stored or held in the same spot, like other radioactive isotopes, so for safety you ideally handle it in very small amounts.

Perhaps to save some money, the company was handling it in larger amounts.

Also, we noticed a lot of issues with the glove box - people getting contaminated, so perhaps the company had ignored installing a more robust replacement for cost reasons, causing more contamination incidents in the process.

Also, some of the tools they used within the glove box may have been "acceptable but outdated" which could cause more stress on the gaskets and glove arms - leading to more risk of contamination.

What was going on with the truck they were pulling apart


They probably cut corners in some other part of processing and the truck was contaminated - they needed to "make it disappear" since they were obviously far too dishonest to report an Incident (as they would have been legally required to).

Was the company purposely contaminating work areas to harm the workers?


No, they were likely just being cheap and causing safety gaps by cutting corners too much.

Once Karen started coming after them, who knows if the security guy may have spiked her with some hot plutonium to try and shut her up (and make her look incompetent)... the movie (and the real facts) certainly seems to imply that they ran her off the road and took the paperwork she had collected.

The only thing I'm 100% sure about


Yes correct - they had to do X-ray photos of each assembly to make sure they were top notch - and their own QA guy was altering records so they could avoid rejecting the defective components. That's SUPER scary, and not cool in any way.

When engineered properly, nuclear fission power is quite safe - but a contractor cutting corners like that is what can make it not safe.

Also when Karen had to stay back to clean up the cake she spilt, how did she get contaminated?


My thought is that despite the company being evil and cutting corners, Karen was probably quite the rebel herself - she may have gotten lazy and skipped a step in the procedure for doing something or other... so she may have initially dosed herself due to her own negligence combined with substandard safety culture/equipment.

reply

Seriously...thank you! I truly appreciate you writing all of that and being so informative!!!

All my questions and confusions have been solved and made sense of.

Again...thank you so much!

reply

no problem - glad I could clarify some of the things they didn't explicitly cover

reply

[deleted]

There's a lot of "may have", "likely", "perhaps", etc. in that explanation. So it's not really clear what the company was doing wrong, or even if they were doing anything wrong. It's a standard "corporation bad--workers good" story.

reply

I felt the same way actually watching the film. Not so much about the company not doing anything wrong but more how Karen and the workers just didn't seem to understand how seriously dangerous their jobs were.

The scene in the beginning where the worker cleans up Karen's gum with the gloves that have just been handling the radioactive material is a classic case, later when they are too busy with cake and presents when they should be doing their jobs. It just seems like they are all goof off's. Even if the company never explained how dangerous this stuff was, surely it doesn't take a genius to know it is?



Sometimes a movie or tv show plot is so stupid that only the stupid can understand it.

reply

Yes, but you could viably argue that the company never made efforts to teach the workers about safety. That’s why the workers acted so irresponsibly, they didn’t know.

The company was sleazy. They had the x-ray cover up. They had a vet working as a doctor. They shadily disposed that truck in the middle of the night etc etc etc

reply

[deleted]