MovieChat Forums > El Norte (1984) Discussion > What Was Wrong With Rosa?

What Was Wrong With Rosa?


Because in the version that I saw,
it never told us.
What was wrong with her?
Why did she die?

reply

OBVIOUS SPOILER:






Rosa dies of an infection she received when he and Enrique were crossing into the US through an old sewer line. As they were going through, a group of rats attacked them and bit her several times. That's why the doctor is quite horrified when he gets the results from her examination.

reply

OOOOh OK. It never showed us anything about that on my version.

reply

u dont want to its a really creepy scene

reply

[deleted]

She contracted typhus from the fleas on the rats.

reply

What version would not have that scene? And why would it be edited anyways? It's important in the end because it shows the price that they paid to make it in el norte ends up killing them in the end. They pass through the depths of the earth to make it to the promised land and in the end, that's what does her in.

reply

They released a classroom version which is dramatically cut to about 45 minutes. It's meant to show the struggles and give students insight at opposed to just enjoying the movie. It ends right as she dies.

reply

There never was an authorized "classroom' edition of El Norte - this must have been done by some rogue pirate with no authority - truly disgusting. The film has always been meant to be seen in its full version - the complete running time is 2 hours and 20 minutes. When the new Criterion edition comes out - street date January 20, 2009 according to the Criterion web site - you will be able to see the true - complete version of the film with ALL the scenes. Also it will be a beautifully restored version supervised by director, Gregory Nava. It will include a one hour documentary about the making of the film and a director's commentary that will answer many of the questions about the symbolism of the film as well as many other things. For those who have seen incomplete versions, please see the "real" version - it's quite an experience.

reply

It was probably cut by someone with some connection to ' Blockbuster '.

reply

Murine typhus is what she had which is only spread by rat fleas, regular typhus is spread by body lice which is why the doctor isolated Rosa, so the doctor delaying her proper DX and the cardiac strain, may have killed rosa. So she died a virgin, that's a shame.

Spoiler alert for them spoil sports out there! Y'all like spoiled milk, stop crying over it!

reply

I'm not a doctor, but I play one on IMDb.

reply

I was a medic sweetpea, and I was playing doctor with your woman last night.

Spoiler alert for them spoil sports out there! Y'all like spoiled milk, stop crying over it!

reply

Doubt it. She died of cancer in November.

reply

I meant your mistress.

Spoiler alert for them spoil sports out there! Y'all like spoiled milk, stop crying over it!

reply

That couldn't be, either. I've never cheated on any woman I've been with. That might be your style or your father's style. Not mine.

reply

My father got tired of my mother as I am nowadays. Most men have left her and U know what buckaroo, I don't blame them!

Spoiler alert for them spoil sports out there! Y'all like spoiled milk, stop crying over it!

reply