MovieChat Forums > The Thing (1982) Discussion > another remake happening

This kickstarter is for the book Frozen Hell. This post is about the movie. More about the book on the project page.
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/wildsidepress/frozen-hell-the-book-that-inspired-the-thing/posts/2740158

Executive Producer Alan Donnes has posted this on Facebook:

It's OFFICIAL! I received my signed contract and first check! I am Executive Producing a remake of THE THING but with additional chapters of John Campbell's groundbreaking novel, Frozen Hell, that had been lost for decades.

Now, for the first time ever, Campbell's full vision will be realized on the big screen. The new film will include the very best of RKO's THE THING FROM ANOTHER WORLD, John Carpenter's classic THE THING and both books, Frozen Hell and Who Goes There?

reply

I never considered The Thing a remake, rather another movie based on Who Goes There?. Who knows, with the new material and the right people it might be good. It probably won't be, but we can hope.

reply

Yeah. It's so different than the 50s the Thing. A lot closer to the Campbell story, actually.

reply

Agreed. Hawks added a freaking romance angle, changed and added characters, not to mention completely changing, you know, the thing! Carpenter was much more faithful to Campbell's novella.

reply

The truth for me is the more versions the better, everyone who's been inspired by the novel is already a director of a potential new version, always deserving to make a movie based on it, cause everyone sees the same thing differently. The same is true about any good film or story, it deserves infinite number of versions or remakes, not stories that dont work. That's why we have 100s of reworkings of great theatrical plays or symphonies. That is a natural way of life, no one owns anything, all things are done based on pre-existing things, which is true about every single thing in the universe, we use existing things to make something out of it to be original. Campbell's story was already based on stories made before it, it's an ancient myth, just like Lovecraft's Mountain of Madness or Bram Stoker's Dracula, it's all based on ancient myths. Carpenter's film and 2011 version received a very limited number of fans, cult audience, the only film that has received the mainstream wider audience is the original, I think the novella has a lot to offer to new visions and talents. Paradox is that if Carpenter's version was the ultimate take on it, then it means the film's story has nothing to say to anyone anymore at this time, when I think it has, think about how many ways you could portray the paranoia, the characters trapped in those situations, how many ways you could do it, it's an incredible wealth of creativity waiting there.

reply

A high bar to jump...1982 Carpenters The Thing is perfect.

Interesting to me that people seem to be more Ok with remakes of sci fi classics than standard movie classics.

You never hear..Godfather has a remake, or a new Clockwork Orange is in the works...

reply

Of course he is.

But not me. Ive been shining these.

I suppose it has to do with the updated cgi.

reply

https://www.instagram.com/p/CESYU0lAMwU/
Carpenter is involved in the 'reboot' with Blumhouse

I guess the term 'reboot' will be the same as when it was used for The Predator, Halloween 2018 and Terminator Salvation/Genisys etc... i.e. a sequel

reply

A sequel could be interesting! I really hope it will not be a "true" reboot, since the 2011 movie was practically a reboot disguised as a prequel (as another user on these forums put it brilliantly).

I'm cautiously optimistic, because I burned myself pretty badly recently with Cameron's involvement in Terminator: Dark Fate, but if Carpenter is involved here, let's hope he still remembers what exactly made his 1982 movie the classic it is.

reply

After Alan Donnes died from that "ear infection" this project are in limbo. The script was also deemed weak as it focused too much on the Norwayland aspect of the story. It's being rewritten to showcase more Americans heroes and turn those foreigners into the antagonist.

Hopefully it will feature an all black cast.

reply

Eh, this movie wouldn’t do as well with an all negro cast. Come on now, a group of negros at an outpost in deep Alaska? Don’t think so

reply

Its Antarctica brother , Antarctica! Not Alaska.
I don't find it unrealistic with an all negro scientist team. Maybe from the all negro Ivy League Morehouse College (Atlanta, GA)

FYI:
There are no countries in Antarctica, although seven nations claim different parts of it: New Zealand, Australia, France, Norwayland, London, Chile, and Argentina. The Antarctic also includes island territories within the Antarctic Convergence

reply

And its my favourite continent.

Maybe they should also have an all female cast, since Carpenter's movie had an all male cast.

reply

Goes without saying !

reply

Yes, sorry, it’s been a while since I saw the flick. But my question still remains. Very unrealistic to find a group of Negros hanging out in the snow, never mind a group of smart negros in one place at the same time

reply

YES...EVERYONE HEARD YOU SAY NEGRO...SEVERAL TIMES...YOU ARE SUPER COOL,EDGELORD.

reply

I’m 12 years old, you keep stalking me and now you found me on my instagram account. You are a pedophile. Now stop it

reply

THE HITS JUST KEEP COMING...COMEDIC GOLD...GIVE THE KID A ROUND OF APPLAUSE.👏🏾

reply

I'm sure Jordan Peele would do this in a heart-beat.

He'd probably have "The Thing" start out as a married white middle-aged man, though.

reply