MovieChat Forums > Sophie's Choice (1983) Discussion > Why was that librarian so rude to her?

Why was that librarian so rude to her?


Right before she faints. It's his job, isn't it? To help her? But he's such a jerk!! It infuriates me because Sophie's such a sweetheart. It upsets me.

CDEGFEDCC. (Shhh!)

reply

Remember the period! There were, I suppose many holocaust and other war survivors flooding the neighborhoods. And considering how racist people were back then, and how a librarian could easily consider a sickly looking girl with such broken english inferior to him, I don't find it shocking. In fact, I find it still very relevant. I'm an Indian, and I've been treated the same way (although admittedly, not that harshly) by the French with jobs like ticket bookers during my stay in Paris. It's very sad that such biases still exist, especially because I guess many outsiders, like me, want to embrace other cultures with such rich histories like the French, and a few people malign the happy hospitality of these countries.

I'm considering going to the US for my post-graduation this summer, and this would be my first time going to the US. From what I've heard, the US is a very diversity-friendly country, and I'm optimistic about my education and stay there. I find it a bit reassuring when Sophie says that she's eaten more good in the US in six months that in her whole life. Although that probably wouldn't be the case with me (I'm a vegetarian), it gives me hope that I'd make some good friends and have a happy stay. I'm lucky that I'm not as broken and injured as Sophie! Have there been anyone else on here who've shifted to other countries esp. to the US, and can in some ways relate to Sophie's experience?

reply

shaguniitb, bless you. I hope the US welcomes you with flowers and open arms!

Love me, love my

reply

I would highly recommend that you watch A Gentleman's Agreement starring Gregory Peck. It deals with the prejudice that many Jews faced after World War II. actually it's set later than this film, but it's enlightening.



There's something here that doesn't make sense. Let's go and poke it with a stick.-Doctor Who

reply

[deleted]

Just to update you guys!

As planned, I moved to the US, and have been here for six months now. I've to say, I'm very pleased with the way the people here treat the outsiders. It's a very open, welcoming country, and I'm glad that I came here, and hope to contribute positively, and give back.

reply

That's great. Welcome!




I want the doctor to take your picture so I can look at you from inside as well.

reply

Shag - Welcome aboard to the USA. We are happy to have you here. Good luck and best wishes!

reply

To shaguniitb, I hope that your life in the US is going well. I am just curious which part of the country you are living in. Sadly some parts are more open to outsiders than others.

reply

He is just an arrogant prick. No need for further explanation. He has a high opinion of himself, yet he is a librarian, so he has to compensate by taking it out on others. Not an uncommon type. One runs across them all the time. He was so cruel because he could be. Sophie was an easy mark - a foreigner with no friends who could not fight back.

reply

Ah, I've just gotten up to this part in the novel. The librarian's name is Weis I think. The reason Sophie passes out isn't just out of exhaustion - but because he reminds her of a Nazi. Makes more sense in the novel.

CDEGFEDCC. (Shhh!)

reply

Pauline Kael said the same thing in her original review, the librarian is basically another Nazi.

reply