MovieChat Forums > Danton (1983) Discussion > Thankfully this interpretation views Dan...

Thankfully this interpretation views Danton favorably


So little still remains of Danton's actual words that his gruff manner has created a negative image of this important figure who's personal ethics took a drastic turn after Robespierre did the opposite in turning from more pacifist in his earlier views into the most vile and murderous paranoiac. Danton, in a reverse fashion, turned from a more violent nature to a more sympathetic figure.
The pantheist historian Alphonse de Lamartine was responsible for creating what in my opinion is a false assessment of Danton as an opportunist, "devoid of honor, principles, and morality" in his own words. However Lamartine, also viewed Mohammed as a pacifist at heart, an opinion not even Muslim clerics cling to. I was delighted to see this cinematic interpretation of Danton's character and impetus as being in a more favorable and sympathetic vein, portraying his reversal of ethics as empathetic and honorable, displaying his deep love and loyalty to the French public and even at the very end demonstrating kindness and more devoid of personal ambition than his critics would have you believe. To those critics of GĂ©rard Depardieu, I say humbug. He stands as one of the greatest historical actors of all time. And the historical accuracy he promulgates through his demeanor, his expressionism and his thespian acumen are matchless in the annals of historical moviemaking. I think you get my point. I just love the guy. He's a delight to watch, but particularly in films that deal with French history. He really shines in this one. The Poles, like Polanski, too, are quite excellent at the art of cinema.

reply

I also like how this movie doesn't paint a simplistic portrait of Danton. At the same time I think its good how the movie lets one of Danton's victims has his say, so to speak: this is in the scene in which a prisoner grabs Danton and tells him how Danton was responsible for the deaths of the prisoner's family members.

I agree with you that Depardieu is excellent. And I think that many of the less-heralded Poles do a great job in the movie too.

reply

Have you read A Place Of Greater Safety by Hilary Mantel? I'm ploughing through it at the moment, it's a brilliant depiction of the world of the Revolution, following Danton, Robespierre and Desmoulins from childhood to death. The portrayal of Danton is particularly interesting, and a very sympathetic one so far - granted, I've not actually reached the revolution, he's still a barrister - and a brilliantly written, lively novel. Apparently very accurate, too. Most of the conversations featured are based on actual ones.

reply