MovieChat Forums > Sengoku jieitai Discussion > reason this film is great

reason this film is great


Well, its a reason to like the film more than just for the ideas commited to celluloid. If this film was made now it would suck as the soldiers or whoever was zapped back in time would spend all their time trying not to pick sides and making as little an impact as possible. This film however tells the story of what you would like the story to be. One where the future people decide to take over the world. madness ensues.... great

Insert flame here. I know you want to. I can see it in your eyes :(

reply

I agree with you, this movie is refreshingly realistic in the human sense. When given the chance to go back in time with superior weaponry the temptation to use that power to dominate is great.

I've seen this movie a long time ago in a german theater, back then it had the title Time Slip. It took a while to track it down on the internet but I found an import with english subtitles, G.I. Samurai, and bought it. There was a lot that I didn't remember about this movie and it was great watching it again. I love time travel/alternate reality movies and this one is one of the better ones.

reply

There's a reason? This movie is garbage! Got it with the Samurai Collection. They all can't be gems. This one was just bad!

reply

[deleted]

No, it wasn't great. Barely good. And there's NO bloody reason for it to be nearly 140 minutes long. The battle scenes go ON and ON and ON long after they could have made they're point, and the choreography and design of these sequences--even for Japan, circa 1979, are clumsy and repetitive. These sequences NEED a sense of the strategies being employed by either side in the battles (especially the seemingly endless climactic war), but instead they're just scene after scene of massive numbers of extras running onto a big field while smoke bombs and strangely dusty explosions go off around them, sending them flailing, while Sonny and his boys act all macho and/or scared as they gradually run out of ammo, fuel and vehicles. Watch the guns of the soldiers during these sequences, 90% of the time there's no muzzle flare, just sound effects.

And for those who think Chiba and co. decide to use their superior weaponry for domination, think again: they ONLY use the weaponry to wipe out the enemies of the power-hungry general they befriend. When all the toys are largely gone, and Sonny beheads the enemy leader, only THEN does Chiba declare that the will end up ruling the era, in part because he knows he and his unit are never going to get back home, and in part because he knows such a declaration will draw the wrath of the general they aided, and indeed this general ultimately kills Chiba, with the remaining troops getting theirs soon after. The fact that their corpses are given respectful treatment, and NOT severed heads, is key. The general still respects them, and more than likely knew they could not have taken control of the land. But custom dictated that they must die.

Regardless, this film is an overblown B-movie. Good concept, but the execution was lacking severely. And the special optical effects during the Time Slip . . . ugh!

reply

The general didnt kill Iba, one of his own men shot him.

My theory is that the general was some kind of important historical figure in japan (like George Washington is to the US) and the cowardly soldier panicked at the last minute and shot Iba so that he wouldnt duel the general and possibly kill him, irreversibly changing history BIG TIME!

That is how I interpreted the ending at least. Good, fun movie, but it needs serious trimming on the runtime.

And what was up with the 6 dudes running a train on the japanese lady with the incredible cans?

Weird movie.

reply