When and where did you see these films for the first time?
I prefer Raiders when I compare it to the rest of the series, although I still enjoy Temple, and I'm indifferent to Crusade. I hated the Crystal Skull though.
I think the main reason for favouring one film over the others, depends on which film you saw first and how old you were. I was born in 76, and watched Raiders in summer of 1981 at the theatre, so made quite an impact. Not to mention the fact it was scary for a young viewer.
I didn't watch Temple until it premiered on BBC1(uk) during Christmas 1987, age 11. Even though I didn't see it at the theatre for some reason when released in 1984, it still made an impact and I found it a much darker picture. That said, it still lacked a certain something compared to Raiders.
I still think if I watched Temple first, my opinion would probably be different.
By the time Crusade was released I was 13-14 and I think this dampened my enjoyment of the third film, plus the expectations of Raiders and Temple set the bar very high.
I tend to find people born in the early to mid 80s tend to prefer Temple, while those born in the 90s prefer Crusade. Obviously I can't speak for everyone, just some people I've had conversations with over the years.
Your thoughts?