why give up MANHATTEN?


its one of the most important places in the U.S , why would they turn it into a jail ?






"when the pirates of the Carribean brake down the pirates don't eat the tourists " Jurassic Park

reply

Because it got so bad it probably wasn't worth saving. In reality it would never happen. But in the fictional universe of Escape series its a place that was run so into the ground it probably couldn't be saved. So it was decided to build a giant wall around it and throw criminals inside there and let them be.

No way would it happen because I wouldn't want criminals to have the amount of freedom they seem to be given. I mean you get the whole island of Manhattan to run around in although dangerous people will probably prefer that than a jail cell. So I think something like that would allow more murderers and rapists to no care about getting caught because if they are then thrown into a place they can roam freely.

reply

The book by Mike McQuay explains this in detail.

"It had once been called New York City but that, like Hauk’s fortitude, had been before the craziness. Now it was the New York Maximum Security Penitentiary and it held three million killers, cutthroats, thieves and lunatics.

And Bob Hauk, God help him, was in charge.

He let his eyes drift over the corpse of the city. It was a blackened shell, a concrete forest of dead, towering trees. Its lifeless towers stretched like monstrous tombstones into the heart of the black night. Occasional fires flickered below him; the animals who now controlled those dead streets were playing out the disease that ruled their minds. But soon it would be winter, and the animals would grow a lot fewer in number. Hauk figured that couldn’t help but be a good thing.

New York City had been the first North American target in the war. It was under siege for three full weeks with fire bombs and gas. When it was over, those who were left alive were crazy. They roamed the streets in large packs, desecrating and cannibalizing what bodies they found. What remains there were got piled in layers up and down Wall Street, and that section of town became known as the boneyard, He hated to look at it, hated everything about it. He hated the fates that put him there to begin with.

The war went on, and so did the gas. As the years slipped by, the American economy went to pieces. There were a lot of poor people, who were going crazy with gas madness. To survive they turned to crime. The crime rate doubled, then redoubled and quadrupled as crazies took to the streets, looting and burning-destroying everything that they came in contact with.

And as the wars continued overseas, the soldiers slowly went crazy. The Army, though, had learned to channel the insanity into battle fury. The trouble was, the boys were starting to come home after years on the front with no way to direct their madness.

Then someone had a bright idea. The United States Police Force was formed, its ranks filled exclusively with veterans with a taste for blood. Their uniforms were black, just like their minds. Their justice was swift and fiery.

They took to the streets, trained to mayhem, and fought the urban wars with clipped military precision. When they were done, millions lay dead. Those unlucky enough to be left alive were herded onto Manhattan Island. It was big enough, and uninhabited by anyone sane, and its rivers formed a natural barricade."

I'm straight up lovable, son.

reply

[deleted]

It's a great read. It really gets inside Snake's head, revealing his motivations. It also fleshes out Hauk. It's the rare instance where the novelization, done for marketing is its own entity. The Star Wars novel, ghost written by Alan Dean Foster has some of that (due more to the deleted scenes included in it); but, not to the level here. I kick myself for letting my copy go (especially since it goes for high dollars, even in used grades); but, I have a digital version.


Fortunately, Ah keep mah feathers numbered for just such an emergency!

reply

[deleted]

NYC was a big mess in the 70s. High crime, high debt. That was probably on the author's mind. The new Alcatraz.

reply

Why give up Manhattan? Because "Escape From New York" sounds more interesting than "Escape From Staten Island". There are dozens of New York islands, most of which are small. Rikers Island has been used as a jail since the 1930s.

reply

Because New York City was a pretty terrible place at the time. This movie was a commentary on that, among other things.

Anyone here mentions Hotel California dies before the first line clears his lips.

reply

I think it's everything already mentioned, plus a lot of people really hate musical theater.

reply

[deleted]

Because who would want to see ESCAPE FROM CLEVELAND?

reply

Because who would want to see ESCAPE FROM CLEVELAND?


I'm pretty sure "the residents of Cleveland" is the correct answer to this question. ;-)

reply