MovieChat Forums > Clash of the Titans (1981) Discussion > Why are they speaking English in this?

Why are they speaking English in this?


This is supposed to be like in ancient times. Didn't they speak Roman or something back then?????

reply

Because otherwise poor souls like you would be unutterably confused at the lack of English and wander off to twerk or text or twitter or something.

reply

Oh my, that was a good one. 


http://jerzygirl45.wordpress.com/

reply

Your the one who would wonder off to twerk or text or twitter or something.

reply

Oooh, BURN!

reply

Well, this was a movie made by English speaking people.... and movies made by English speaking people tend to speak English... LOL. But seriously, I don't think that (if they HSD don't tgis in the appropriate tongue) that it would have been in Roman.... wouldn't it have been in Greek?

reply

Err.. that should have said...
(if they had don't this in the appropriate tongue)*

reply

Why are you such a troll?

Why am I feeding you right now?

reply

a. It's Greek mythlogy, not Roman.
b. Would you understand it in ancient Greek? Even with subtitles I suspect you'd be hard pressed to keep up.
c. There's no such language as Roman. The Romans spoke Latin.

reply

Thank you! A rare intelligent poster! You are a bright candle amidst the darkness.

reply

Yeah very few movies use what should be the actual language spoken. 'Valkyrie' from a few years ago was set in Nazi Germany but I don't recall Tom Cruise speaking German throughout. Heck why do the main Star Wars characters speak English? That can't be right. In fact the only recent film that did use authentic languages that comes to mind is 'The Passion of the Christ' - wasn't that done in Latin, Greek, Hebrew and Aramaic? But that is the exception to the rule, those are few and far between.

reply

It's so you can understand and don't walk out because you "go to the movies to watch movies, no to read".

Source: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/TranslationConvention

reply

Look, first of all, this was a film designed for English-speakers to watch, not ancient Greeks. Second, most people understand that when they're watching ancient people speak English, they use their imaginations and realize that the characters are speaking ancient Greek, but we hear English so we know what they're saying to each other.

It's a common understanding more intelligent movie audience members have when watching a film where it's pretty obvious the characters wouldn't speak English for real, but the actors are doing it for clarity.

reply

Not to be an a ho but I appreciate the English part because it's the only language with which I am fluent.

reply