MovieChat Forums > Hill Street Blues (1981) Discussion > Anti-Semitic remark directed toward at D...

Anti-Semitic remark directed toward at Det. Goldblume


When Det. Goldblume states his name with the megaphone during the negotiations, a voice (presumably a fellow cop) says "Jews." I have not seen this troubling epithet addressed anywhere online or on this forum, but that statement is patently anti-Semitic and it serves to illustrate how anti-Semitism in the U.S. is not only ignored, but accepted. What makes matters worse is that Det. Goldblume does "nothing" to react to the statement "Jews" which only confirms that he has accepted the fact that anti -is the "accepted norm" in the community where he lives and works. Tragically, I still see this in modern TV and film, like the movie 'Neighbors' where character Kelly Radner says to her husband Mac "Don't call your mother! Jesus Christ! You Jews and your mothers!" Even if this line was written by a Jew, AND it's considered "funny and acceptable" to Seth Rogan and all the other Jewish cast and crew, it's NOT considered amusing or acceptable to many other Jews. For some reason if anti Semitism is written by Jews and performed by them, then it's allowed to "pass" unchallenged.

reply

I'm curious: have you been to The Golden Girls forum to register your pain over calling grown women "girls?" How about all the shows in the fifties which referred to black Americans as "Negroes," when they deigned to refer to them at all? The world is waiting for you to reveal the terrible, hidden truth--people in the past expressed bigotry in ways which are no longer acceptable!

Clearly, the scene in HSB to which you refer was not intended to promote anti-semitism. It served to give a dramatic presentation of the persistence of prejudice. Goldblume's non-response illustrated the circumstances in which he lived and worked, knowing that nothing he said or did would make a difference, that, in fact, any reaction would be seen as foolish and unnecessary.

The audience were supposed to see this and realize the sort of garbage that Goldblume had to deal with. This is a laudable goal, not something for someone thirty years later to come here and express outrage over. Would it be better if we pretended that prejudice didn't exist, that everyone gets along regardless of differences?

I'd suggest you dismount that high horse you're perched on in this instance and save your shock for more relevant, destructive examples of bigotry--for instance, the self-righteous Israeli slaughter of Palestinians.

reply

I gotta say that it is not endorsin anti-semitism but rather depicting the real world, no?

reply

Henry's faith was reacted to more than once, always, as the good Dr above says, to highlight prejudice, not to foster it. Having watched the whole series, do think writers like these would show their anti-Semitism by having a voice in a crowd say "Jews"?

Everyone in the cast had their ethnicity mocked or abused to a greater or lesser degree - remember "Pizza Man"? Remember the Chief getting Joe Coffee and Officer Perez confused? Remember Howard's constant, friendly (as he saw them) references to Lt Calletano's Hispanic heritage? Or Renko referring to him as "that chubby little caballero" (fat-shaming AND racist!)

The show was refreshingly free of political correctness (a concept unheard of at the time). Howard and Renko were good people - they spoke as people of the time spoke. If you wanted to get precious about every utterance in HSB, you could fill a whole IMDB by yourself.

reply

Hunter had references for everyone, of every faith & every race. And most would just give him a look, idiot, smile & move on. When I watch, I chuckle, because it was purposely done.

reply

Everyone in the cast had their ethnicity mocked or abused to a greater or lesser degree - remember "Pizza Man"?


Pizza Man has nothing to do with ethnicity. It's a reference to the first or second time Frank asked Joyce out on a date. He didn't have a lot of money at the time, so he suggested Pizza, because it was all he could afford. Despite all the teasing and what today would be considered questionable language, they all got along and supported each other. I can't imagine Hunter letting someone from other precinct insult Goldblume without getting a verbal reprimand.

"Forget reality, give me a picture"-Remington Steele

reply

I read that recently on another thread, thanks. I wonder which came first, the nickname or the explanation? Just that the explanation may have been retro-fitted to soften the harsh (ish) nickname (though also harmless, in my eyes). It could be seen as tactless - like calling a black character "Watermelon Man" because he was the CEO of a watermelon conglomerate!

reply

[deleted]

That sounds nice but unfortunately I do not believe it is true. In 1982 Travanti appeared on an episode of Saturday Night Live where he reprised his role as Captain Furillo. Somebody playing the part of Joyce Davenport called him Pizza Man. He took exception to it and explained he was not from Southern Italy but Northern Italy which was closer to Switzerland. He said and he preferred a completely different kind of food than pizza and gave wonderful sounding examples. I thought it was hilarious because it always seemed obvious to me that she was using Pizza Man as an ethnic joke.

reply

Report immediately to the "safe area", Frank. Everything will be okay.

reply

Dan Hedaya's corrupt Ralph McAfee addressed Det. Washington as "Sunburn". Many of the black neighborhood tough guys call Renko "Chuck meat". They also called Bobby Hill an Uncle Tom.

It happened throughout the run of the show. It was the 80's. The term "Political Correctness" hadn't been mentioned yet.

We were on our way to Midnight Mass!

reply

The term "politcial correctness" had actually been around since the '60s, but it meant something copletely different until right-wingers hijacked in the early '90s (1992,to be exact) to dismiss anything that dealt with the concerns of women and people of color bringing attention to issues like racism and sexism, and how it affects them in ways that it never affects white men,

reply

Chuckle 😀 My husband And I loved this show! named our first dog we had as a couple after Belker lol

reply

You do realize this was made in 1981???? Times before political correctness??? SMH...

reply

I would be interested to know who wrote that episode.

reply

Great for an opening salvo, then we break into

*your theme song* --

"They see me trollin'
and baitin'
They tryin' to catch me writin' dirty!"

reply