The book


I am huge fan of the Shining movie but have never read the book. Is there anything in Stephen King’s book that helps the movie make sense in some areas, or are all the mysteries within in the movie just specific to Kubrick’s adaptation?

reply


Safe to say there's next to nothing in the book that clears up this movie's mysteries.

This is very definitely a Kubrick film that just happens to use King's novel as a plot source

I should confess though that the novel is one of my least favorite among's King's "early" works (i.e. his short fiction and novels up through Needful Things)

reply

Yeah, Kubrick just pretty much did his own thing. It's just another poor adaptation, like The Bourne Identity.

reply

Heres somthing cool about the book and its sequel dr sleep. Spoilersssss.......
Btw I reccomend both books i really loved them













I remember in the book,it was implied that at the end. With Jacks last bit of sanity and love left in him for his family. He was able to sub consciously forget to release the pressure valve on the boiler. Causing the hotel to blow up, and allowing Wendy and danny and the black dude to escape.



At the end of dr sleep danny takes on a powerful clairvoyant foe atop the burned remains of the hotel. In the fight at the last minute he is assisted with a shove to his foe from a family related specter. You can geuss who that was . Jack of course. Now this how i remember these books ending, but maybe im wrong ? Tell me if so. I do smoke pot so maybe im foggy about the details. But i remember both times being very moved at the thought of jack redeeming him self not once but twice. A fathers love for his family gets me every time

reply

I don't think that happened in the movie. They had Danny sacrifice himself to mirror his father's sacrifice from the first book, but I don't recall Jack appearing outside the bar conversation (which is just the hotel talking to Danny more or less).

reply

Yea thats right. Jacks character ark gets the shaft in the movies

reply

Which is why, while I do enjoy Kubric's Shining, I much prefer the book. The character is so vastly different, and even likeable in the book.

reply

Check Dr. Sleep too! You can see what it's like for the traumatized son of an alcoholic, as he struggles with his genetic legacy. I feel like it's the perfect continuation of Jack's story.

reply

I really liked Doctor Sleep. I really liked the book, and I thought that Flannigan did a pretty decent job at making an adaptation of the book, and a sequel Kubrick's movie.

reply

Yeah. Jack Torrance was a deeply flawed individual that succumbed to his alcoholism and aggressive tendencies, though he had that moment of redemption where he set up the building to blow. It always moves me when he tells his son to run (or something like that) shortly before he's taken over completely by the evil.

You don't get that in Kubrick's film. He's just a time bomb without any hope for redemption.

reply

During his conversation with Grady, Jack claims to have read about him in the newspaper. We never see that happen and he didn’t know about the tragedy during his interview. But there is a brief shot of a scrapbook by his typewriter at one point. The book goes into great detail about the scrapbook Jack finds in the basement and everything he learns from it.

reply

The book tells us why Jack was fired from his teaching position (violence against a student) and how that experience influences his new writing project.

reply

Even though this isn’t mentioned in the movie, you can see Jack wearing a Stovington Prep T-shirt at one point.

reply

The book tells us Danny’s full name: Daniel Anthony Torrance. Get it? Tony.

reply

I just finished reading the book for the first time (my mother gave me her first printing, which is in almost mint condition, and complete with its dust jacket-it's probably worth money).

I too, was wondering if the book would clear up any mysteries that were left unanswered in the film. Unfortunately, they are so far removed from one another, that reading the book adds nothing to the film. It's as if Kubrick was influenced by the original story, and borrowed a few things from the novel, but ended up writing his own story. Yeah, the shine is there, the hotel is there, the ghosts are there, the characters are there, but everyone, and everything is put together completely different. A lot is added, a lot is left out, so what we got was a very different story.

reply

Which cover does the book your mom gave you have? Is it the Warren Beatty looking one?

reply

Yes, that's the one. Although my mother and I always thought that he looked more like Charles Grodin.

reply

Yes! Ha That’s who I think it looks like also but didn’t know if you’d get the reference.

reply

That's who I thought it was the first time I saw the cover. I only saw the original cover for the first time about 5-6 years ago. Up until that point I had only seen the paper back cover.

reply

I HIGHLY RECOMMEND reading/listening to the book. It is phenomenal. And the answer is both. Some things the book expands on/makes more clear. Just as an example, the scene where Wendy comes up on the man in the bear suit going down on the man on the bed. The man on the bed was one of the owners of the hotel who is a closeted homosexual. And the guy in the costume, which was a dog costume in the book not a bear costume, was one of his flings. It also expands on how Jack got the job there and why he's not teaching anymore. And then also some of the stuff you see in the movie is not in the book. But are Kubrick's own variations of what's in the book. A lot of people complain about how different the movie is from the book but what you never hear them talk about is how a lot of the stuff is exactly the same as the book. Especially the dialogue some of it is verbatim directly from the book. Anyway the book and the movie are both awesome and I highly recommend both.

reply

Agreed, the book spends a lot of time going in to the back story of the hotel. Just like the man and the bear suit and the parties are explained, they also give the back story of the woman in the bathtub.

There is also a lot more insight into the family dynamics. From Danny’s perspective at least.

reply

Truly one of the best horror novels ever written.

reply