MovieChat Forums > The Shining (1980) Discussion > Considering The Shining's subtext, what ...

Considering The Shining's subtext, what would Kubrick think of "Wokism"


I very strongly feel that this film is under the surface saying a lot about America's (and also West's) history of imperialism and racism, and how these cultural artefacts are carried on from one Empire (British) to another (America), from one generation to another, from father to son. This is the sort of discussion about American history that Florida Governor Ron De Santis has passed laws to limit (The Anti-Woke Laws) this year.

On the other hand, Kubrick was a keen student of history, not just American history. Kubrick was also deeply, profoundly skeptical of the human race, and seemed rather cynical about man's ability to change his stripes. He also seemed a fiercely independent and Libertarian streak, although with a decidedly leftward leaning. So he likely would have been rather opposed to some of the more extreme and anti-free speech aspects of "Wokism", and also skeptical that black, brown and female people on the micro level and non-Western nations on the macro level would be any more likely to avoid the pitfalls of humanity as they gained power and equality in society and on the world stage.

I am thinking about the dispute that Kubrick had with Kirk Douglas and Dalton Trump while making Spartacus. As leftists, they clearly saw Spartacus as an heroic, almost Christ-like figure fighting against Imperialism and tyranny. Kubrick, if he had has his druthers, would have taken a more nuanced approach, exploring how Spartacus himself had become somewhat corrupted by his newfound power based on historical records of the time. In other words, Kubrick was too independent to tow a strict party line, even if he mostly was on Spartacus's side. This pattern of iconoclastic independence carried throughout his career.

My personal take is that Kubrick above all was interested in examining power, and power relationships, more so than he was "anti-White" or "anti-America". Not that he had the least reservations about also criticizing the West or America, mind you. So, anyway, what would Kubrick have thought of modern Wokism? We may as well expand this to modern Conservatism as well.

reply

Do we know what Kubrick thought about the hippies?

reply

I'm guessing he didn't care for them that much. Then again, the Yippies* didn't like Hippies either, but not because they weren't Leftists. It's the reason why that's important. Full Metal Jacket would seem to indicate he was no fan of the Vietnam War, although he was fascinated by phenomenon of war and of warrior culture.

*Yippies are different than Yuppies, for those that aren't familiar with this term.

reply

"SJWs" are mostly -if not actually stupid- then rather shallow minded and two dimensional in their thinking, not very intellectual. While they and Kubrick might be fellow travelers on a lot of issues, he wouldn't want anything to do with them.

reply

I wonder if he had been alive when being cancelled for his treatment of Shelley Duvall whether he would have made a groveling apology to save his Hollywood career or if he would have walked away for other pursuits.

reply

OP has convinced me to vote for De Santis.

reply