The Book Was Awesome.


I haven't seen the movie. What's so bad about it?

Some antelopes are vegans -My sister

reply

It would take to long to say what is wrong with the movie just enjoy the book.

reply

Question about the book - in the movie that bit about the Russians coming aboard and the "secret submarine" coming to the rescue looked pretty lame to me. Is it in the book? How about the Dana-Seagram thing? That went nowhere in the movie. Was it in the book and did Cussler do anything with it?

reply

In the book a rescue team came aboard during the storm to retake the ship from the russians they was shot out the torpedo of the sub

In the book also Dirk and Dana did not know one another before they meet on this mission they a one-time flng in one of the staterooms of the ship and that is far as it went

reply

[deleted]

Rescue team shot out of a torpedo tube? And I thought the "secret sub" bit was lame. I may have to read this book - it might improve my opinion of the movie (which had its good points - the special effects were pretty good, especially the Titanic breaking the surface, and I'm a Richard Jordan fan and he never looked better. I also thought the scenes with Alec Guiness were marvelous, he made me feel like maybe the darned ship was worth raising after all)

reply

I think that how it is done in real lfe i am trying to find out for sure.

reply

[deleted]

Actually, I think Alec Guiness could sell me just about anything.

reply

The movie version of Raise the Titanic is like The Ten Commandments without the plagues or the parting of the Red Sea; it is like Ben Hur without the chariot race or the sea battle; it is The Blues Brothers without the music; it is Love Story without anyone dying; it is M*A*S*H without the football game or shower scene; it is Dune without the sandworms.
Everything that made the book exciting was excised. It is an "action" movie without any action. All of that raging battle on the ship with the Russians? Gone. The Russian comes aboard and in a bad accent says "We claim it" - and to the best of my memory, Jason Robards says "Oh yeah, look over there" and ONE fighter jet flies over and the he says "Look over there" and ONE sub surfaces. The Russian shrugs his shoulders and leaves. Then when Robards says he didn't want the Russians to have a byzanium bomb? Huh? Where did that come from?

John Barry's score is good though. I think he reused much of it later.

reply

i read the book 30 years ago this month - and loved it.

Movie has some good points.

The think I most liked about the movie was they changed the ending - in the book the Americans recover the material and test their device. In the movie - they decide to leave it in the ground !!

Cussler was really pissed that they changed this.



http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=32397724

reply

[deleted]

Unless you have 300 million dollars to make a 6 - 10 hour miniseries, there is no way you can do full justice to Cusslers books.

And his dialogue with is funny on the printed page does not translate at all to being spoken.


http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=32397724

reply

I enjoy the film, but never read the book. My dad has it somewhere. He has a lot of those Dirk Pitt books somewhere.


For DEMONIC TOYS and updates on Full Moon Films:
www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply