MovieChat Forums > Raging Bull (1980) Discussion > Raging bull VS Taxi driver VS Goodfellas

Raging bull VS Taxi driver VS Goodfellas


Raging bull is a very good movie. For me it was entertaining and captivating. 8/10

Taxi driver was a bit of a disappointment for me.not very impressive and a bit boring. Still, good performance so 7/10

Goodfellas is my Martin Scorsese classic. As I'm pretty sure I am not the only one. 9/10

reply

The triumverate of Scorsese/DeNiro films. For the record, I prefered Taxi Driver.

reply

Taxi Driver takes top honors for me. Of course, the other 2 films ain't shabby!

reply

All 3 are 10/10.

Goodfellas- Scorsese's most technical film. A story suited for him. Similar to Mean Streets but AFTER he mastered the art. A fast paced, never a bad scene masterpiece. Not just Henry Hill but the Viewer is guided through the Mob for 25 years. Pinnacle of his career.

Taxi Driver- Scorsese and Schrader meet up at a low point in both their lives. One in a massive Drug Addiction, the other a Deep Depression. We see the outcome. Many say that the greatest art can come out of both scenarios and it sure the hell did. A story about Catholic Guilt, Loneliness and the descent into it. A man who wants to be something but can't figure out the world around him. Scorsese really played with the Camera and ut showed. Perfection once again

Raging Bull- Again Scorsese and Schrader team up. Mardik Martin as well. Another character piece but also a period piece. A troubled man who has his life dictate his profession. Again, Machismo and Guilt are layered throughout the film. The study of a very troubled individual. Deeply flawed but somewhat relatable. Technically another score. The camera tells the story beautifully. DeNiro shining, Pesci, Moriarty... Took Scorsese out of his addiction and put him at the Top of American Filmmaking.

All get the highest praise from me. All important for their own reasons

reply

All 3 are 10/10.

Goodfellas- Scorsese's most technical film. A story suited for him. Similar to Mean Streets but AFTER he mastered the art. A fast paced, never a bad scene masterpiece. Not just Henry Hill but the Viewer is guided through the Mob for 25 years. Pinnacle of his career.

Taxi Driver- Scorsese and Schrader meet up at a low point in both their lives. One in a massive Drug Addiction, the other a Deep Depression. We see the outcome. Many say that the greatest art can come out of both scenarios and it sure the hell did. A story about Catholic Guilt, Loneliness and the descent into it. A man who wants to be something but can't figure out the world around him. Scorsese really played with the Camera and ut showed. Perfection once again

Raging Bull- Again Scorsese and Schrader team up. Mardik Martin as well. Another character piece but also a period piece. A troubled man who has his life dictate his profession. Again, Machismo and Guilt are layered throughout the film. The study of a very troubled individual. Deeply flawed but somewhat relatable. Technically another score. The camera tells the story beautifully. DeNiro shining, Pesci, Moriarty... Took Scorsese out of his addiction and put him at the Top of American Filmmaking.

All get the highest praise from me. All important for their own reasons


 Great post!

reply

All excellent films but Taxi Driver is my favourite. Acting, writing and directing all top notch throughout. I love Raging Bull but feel it slows down a little once he gets fat.

Marlo Stanfield is NOT a man for this town - Omar Little

reply

All classics. Goodfellas is so technically cool.

Also, watch the king of comedy. Very underrated collaboration by these two. Movie is pretty *beep*

reply

I'm really surprised that you didn't love taxi driver. I don't think you hated it which is good but come on! That was perfect method acting! I think it's de niro's best performance. Not his best movie though. I think goodfellas is his best movie, taxi driver and raging bull are equally awesome!

reply

All are 10/10 in my book. I'd say Raging Bull is Scorsese's magnum opus, followed by Taxi Driver and then Goodfellas. Goodfellas is probably the most accessible but Raging Bull is shows Scorsese at the peak of his directorial powers.

reply

Taxi Driver is by far the best. Well-designed; mentally, emotionally and ethically provocative. Artistic. Subversive.

Raging Bull is the least. Everything I just praised Taxi Driver for was lacking in Raging Bull.

reply