I LOVE this movie
I'm still surprised that people hate it so much. I found it several years back in a bargain bin for $3.00 and had never heard of it, and it's been a favorite of mine ever since.
The atmosphere just gets to me— the Staten Island fall setting is just great, and the film is well paced and a bit idiosyncratic as far as slasher films go. Yeah, yeah, yeah, we all can see the "Halloween" influence, and it's definitely an oddball of the bunch, but I've never found it to be any cornier than other slasher flicks of the era— in fact, I'd put it as a cut above most of them. It's deliciously atmospheric and has an unusual (and surprisingly creepy) villain. It's also one of the few slasher films whose killer(s) AREN'T masked.
I dunno, I just find this film so strangely amusing and, for whatever reasons, super atmospheric.