Bullet immunity, but no sword immunity?


As we have been shown, highly-trained Jedi Masters are immune to blaster fire. Han Solo draws pretty quickly, and shoots immediately after, but Darth Vader shrugs and deflects those blaster bullets off, like they're nothing.

In real world, you're safer from swords than bullets. Swords are slow, clumsy, and need to be near you to do any damage, and you might -still- be able to avoid being hit by skillful dodging.

A bullet will mercilessly hit you from far away, and its penetrating power is stronger (depending on the weapon and caliber, of course) than a sword's. And bullets are so fast, they're invisible to us.

In the Star Wars world (it's hard to call a place this small a 'Universe'), however, the Jedi can't have ANY defence against a slowly-moving sword, but can deflect military gunfire as if it's not even there, and invite the shooter for a meal immediately after the fact.

Why can't force protect the Jedi Masters from light sabers? If the ability to destroy a planet is an insignifigant power compared to what the force can do, then SURELY a tiny energy field around a Jedi Master should be doable.

Surely!

Or at least protecting the light saber hand. (Hands get cut off so much in this world, I am sure the Jedi Masters would've devised protection against this common eventuality pretty quickly)

Considering what we have been told, and even if we go purely by what we have been shown the force is able to do, the force is incredibly under-used in these movies!

I am sure any viewer with a bit of imagination can easily come up with anything between 8 and 800 000 different ways to use the force in most situations, where a Jedi master or force user is on screen. But no, Luke throws a rock into a switch and jams a bone down a monster's throat after FALLING through a trap door... after expecting a trap (surely no one is stupid enough to NOT in that situation).

Obi-Wan turns a switch off by walking dangerously on a ledge and then walking back instead of using the force.

And... so .. on.

What the heck is the force, when it can almost never be used, unless it's specifically plot-relevant? They should never have introduced 'the force', or they should've made it way more limited, or access to it very difficult or time-consuming, or something (requiring a proper meditative state that takes an hour to attain, for example).

reply

Well...there's a lot of answers here...

So, in the real world, armour is rated differently. The same kevlar vest that will stop a bullet will be less effective or completely ineffective against knives. So, maybe conjuring energy barriers of different types is possible, but maybe it's harder to do for lightsabres than for blasters.

Or...it might not be the Force. It might be the armour (or a combination). Lightsabres are shown cutting through almost anything, but Luke scores a hit on Vader in his very movie, a hit which deflects off of his shoulder armour. Vader feels the hit, crying out in pain when it happens, but it doesn't cut right through. So, maybe his armour helps him. (I don't really like this explanation - it raises a tonne of questions and doesn't address Force masters' abilities).

Lightsabres are tremendously more powerful than blasters, though. Blast-doors are laser-bullet proof, but clearly not laser-sword proof, as demonstrated many times in the film. The quick damage of the blaster (a brief shot) doesn't compare to holding an energy blade (of considerably greater strength) against the Force master.

Different masters have different levels of power, too. Luke never displays the godlike abilities the Force can bestow while the original trilogy runs. He dimly glimpses the future, that's about it. He moves a few rocks. Vader is stronger, and maybe he can do it - that would explain the glancing blow. The only time Vader is sliced up by a lightsabre is his hand in Return of the Jedi, and he's already quite weak from a prolonged battle. Luke's also tapping into some serious Dark Side-y rage, so maybe he's willing the blade through Vader more than Vader can stop it. It might be harder to block than strike (as in real life - far easier to make a mammoth explosion than prevent that bomb/rocket from blowing a building apart).

reply

Finally, though, the Force is just like a sonic screwdriver or R2-D2 or Gandalf's staff. Like any other sci-fi/fantasy techno-magic, it is a plot-driving stopgap that has whatever the writer needs. It's Q Branch from James Bond.

Now, I think this has become more and more obvious as the series goes on. In Star Wars, it was very mystic and ill-defined, but in a way that worked. Nobody really threw rocks with their minds or anything. It was Enlightenment. It was the ability to transcend death and be "bigger" than mortal universes or problems. By The Empire Strikes Back, it's also seeing the future and telekinesis - more magic powers type stuff.

And then each Episode seems to add new stuff and creates little plot-pockmarks (if not full plot holes) about "How come they don't just _______?"

I think, for the most part, they keep it just nebulous enough for me to buy it and just defined enough to be fun. The perfect balance was, for me, Gandalf. He always could help, but never cleansweep everybody, and it never seemed cheap when he did. Maybe because he came up against foes more powerful, we knew that he had limits. I feel the same way about certainly the original trilogy Force users. Luke can't capriciously pull objects around, they can stop blaster fire, but not sabres, and in general it makes them mighty, but not gods.

But, the short answer is: lightsabres are just a lot stronger than blasters.

reply

Great answer man!
I usually call it "bad writing", because that's what it is. I can't stand this kind of crap, make some rules and stick to it goddamit!
That's one big clue of how awful SW is now: they don't even know the basic rules, it doesn't even make sense anymore, it looks like some idiot "producer" that has never watched the first ones or liked them has decided to write a sequel thinking "I know how to make this better!"

reply

Honestly with Star Wars and fantasy fiction in general there is a certain degree of obligatory suspension of disbelief that you have to enjoy it. Of course in more reason years under Di$ney Star Wars they've been pushing it to an obscene degree.

reply

You're not calling it a universe?
Why do Marvel get a universe and Star wars dosent ? SW covers lots of planetes light years apart - its big.

reply

It's only a galaxy not a whole universe. One that is far, far away I hear.

reply

I'm willing to assume that light sabers have Force-related properties of their own, and that Sith and Jedi cant affect another Force-user's light saber.

reply

>If the ability to destroy a planet is an insignifigant power compared to what the force can do

Dont forget the other person with the lightsaber is also using the force to fight with and premeditate where the next light saber swing will come from

reply

That power insignificance might not even refer to sheer power output, either. I doubt Vader was speaking in terawatts or anything. I think he was referring to the spiritual power it holds. We know, for instance, Jedi and Sith can see the future. If visions are properly read and applied, that foresight would be worth a whole fleet of Death Stars.

reply

In the old EU comics, we did actually see Jedi masters able to deflect lightsaber blades without using a lightsaber themselves.

reply