MovieChat Forums > Tess (1980) Discussion > Angel's struggle with religion and God ....

Angel's struggle with religion and God ...


...

I think it's strange that Angel's crisis of faith and inner turmoil regarding the existence of God was omitted from this adaptation.

In my opinion, Angel is a totally hateful character. He is a hypocrite in the first degree, and selfish. But the MAIN scene that makes me hate him was not shown here. That scene being his conversation with Tess at stonehenge, when she realizes that they've come to the end of their journey, and that her capture and inevitable execution are close at hand.

She is dejected and desperate and asks him if she thinks they will meet again in heaven... and he says NO! Because he doesn't believe in heaven or God, he says. Couldn't the jerk have told a white lie, just to appease his poor wife in one of her most desperate moments? I don't think I've ever been more furious at a fictitious character before.

Was anyone else disappointed that this pivotal, character-defining scene was left out of the movie?



...rolling downhill like a snowball headed for hell...

reply

Yeah, it´s interesting that Polanski (who to my knowledge is atheist) chose to omit that Angel´s reply and replaced it with him just whispering "sheesh". Probably goes to show how personally he took the material vis-a-vis to the dedication to Sharon Tate and all.

Btw is it even mentioned in the movie that the guy had managed to lose his faith somewhere along the line? If so, then I sure missed it.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

Hihihih what's even worse in the novel, he practically hooks up with Tess's sister immediately following her execution.

reply

I agree.
I also felt really angry when Angel didn't answer to Tess's question, which means no, in the novel as much as you did.
He was a real douche bag. He was not only a hypocrite with sexual double standard, but also he was a classist. When he found out about her past, he scorned her being peasant class. That was unforgivable. Tess was blinded by Angel and believed everything he said was true, and never able to see his true worth. That made me mad the most. Tess killed the man whom she chose to live with, and sacrificed her life for Angel, who would never accept her. This is the most tragic event in the whole book.

However, Tess knew the happiness won't last, because Angel would despise her soon or later. Hardy himself admitted Tess and Angel were doomed to unhappiness in any circumstances.

Some people really believe that there was a chance Tess and Angel could be happy together, which is their first encounter at may dance. Latest BBC production emphasized on it. Wrong! Won't anybody get that, they were not destined to be happy together, and they had no chance to fall in love each other at the may dance because he would have never ever noticed her, before her tragic experience at d'Urberville's estate.

reply

I totally agree with all of you.
Angel was as bad as Alec.
I feel he was really worse because Alec did not try and hide who he was.
He only wanted Tess for one thing.
Angel was so high and mighty, I hated Alec for what he did but Angel was just as guilty.
Tess was the true victim of both these men.

reply

[deleted]