Smiths Hotel


I have just finished watching the re run of The Jewel in the Crown and bought a DVD of Staying On. I've looked up hotels and there were two very grand hotels in Shimla one The Grand and the other Clarks. Neither look anything like in the film so they may have got an old colonial house and put "Smiths Hotel" on the portico. A real Smiths Hotel is situated in Glasgow and was established in 1928. I think they picked the name as a likely choice for a modest English style of hotel in the Colonies which was probably started by an Englishman (or Scottish)and then handed over to the new Indian owners.
SkiesAreBlue

reply

While Tusker and wife were characters in the Jewel ...., etc, Staying on was modelled around real characters, the Goodbodys, in Greens Hotel annexe in Belgaum. They, too, were "staying on". My parents lived and worked some 50 miles from Belgaum, and we knew the Goodbodys quite well.

reply

Thank you peter-r-murray what a lovely story and how fabulous to be connected to a great series. I hope the Goodbodys had a better ending than Tusker and his wife.

SkiesAreBlue

reply

SkiesAreBlue, Thanks for your email. Unfortunately the Goodbodys fared no better than the Smalleys. Peter Goodbody had a business maintaining camera bellows (in the days when SLR cameras had fabric bellows for the lens to move in and out), and this is what enabled him to stay on in India - he had a job that couldn't be replaced by a local. The Green's hotel manager's wife was constantly trying to force them out of the annexe so that it could be developed.
The Goodbodys were quite poor, and getting poorer each year. Peter showed me how to resharpen a safety razor blade on the inside of a Rose's marmalade jar - they were that poor. Peter died of a heart attack or stroke, I forget which, on the toilet. His wife Maisie subsequently upped and left back to England, and we lost touch.
As more and more Brits left India, my dad became the area's British High Commission rep., looking after the interests of the remaining Brits. Had the Queen visited India, this would have enabled my parents to be introduced. My mum kept a pair of new white gloves (mandatory in those days)ready, but they were never needed.
I spent my formative years in India, and even though the Raj was over before I got to India, its echoes lingered on, so I really enjoyed the Raj quartet. I developed a real liking for India, visited several times on business and on vacation, and honeymooned there.

reply

Thank you for your very informative email. I suppose based on a true story Paul Scott kept to the truth. Poor Dears, life didn’t deal them with a good hand. My connection with India is that my grandfather worked for the British Petroleum Company in Digboy, Nepal. My grandmother went out there to marry him 1908 and my father was born in Calcutta, 1909. He made a terrible mistake and instead of investing in the Shell Oil Company, he put his money in the hands of a Chinese and never saw his him or his money again. They stayed until post WW1 and on return to England GF could not get a job. Life was probably very dismal after the war and he and GM managed to eke out a living by house-sitting. I only met them once when I was six but my older brothers spent more time with both sets of grandparents. Have you read, The Fishing Fleet? Also I have seen the Marigold movie and I hope to see Part 2. Wonderful acting. I have other connections with India but never been there. These are all distant relatives who lived there under the Raj in one form or another. It would be great to see some of the places spoke so much about. I also had a Great Uncle who ran a tea plantation in Ceylon, he died aged around 30 without issue and in the 50’s the government took over the plantation. We did visit there and were taken to Uncle’s bungalow and Mum said it was just like walking back in time as all his furniture and paintings etc were still there untouched. I wish I could find it now but have had no success.

SkiesAreBlue

reply

Dear SkiesAreBlue,

Thanks for your email. I have found this web address, which explains why you can't identify the Smiths hotel in Simla: https://books.google.com.au/books?id=A00G_xG8uIYC&pg=PA218&lpg=PA218&dq=paul+scott+goodbody&source=bl&ots=QuJ5ihzuo_&sig=7T2c1OAwiYJeGvn-avxJFkN02r4&hl=en&sa=X&ei=gozlVKXRLsu2UYGqgtgM&ved=0CEAQ6AEwBg#v=onepage&q=paul%20scott%20goodbody&f=false

Basically, it doesn't exist, it was composited from other buildings. I hope you find it informative. I have not read The Fishing Fleet, but have just read a synopsis. Looks really interesting. Yes, have seen The Best Marigold Hotel, with ex-wife with whom I honeymooned in India (we're still the best of friends), and will be seeing the new movie as soon as it is released.

What amazing links you have with India/Sri Lanka. My single link is much more prosaic; dad went out to fit textile machinery, being a fitter, and stayed for 25 years, becoming mills general manager, before returning to England for a qiet job and then retirement. I don't obsess with India, or "the old days", because they weren't particularly good old days, but I do have a fascination for India, and other places, too. Well worth taking time out for a holiday, if you are able, especially with all your links to it.

Regards

reply