The phonecall scene


Somebody please explain me that part? i certainly could not find any particular significance to that scene. [Not that i have understood everything else in the film ]

reply

I've looked through a few analyses of the movie to answer that question, and the consensus seems to be that it was an attempt at humor and/or an attempt to make the Zone even more ambiguous (as it may or may not be connected to the real world in some way).

I can't help but feel that there was some more significance to it, however. Professor announces over the phone that he's on the threshold of discovering The Room, and his colleague violently reacts to this declaration.

I interpreted it this way: For Professor and those like him, The Room represents discovery of the unknown. If Professor were to actually discover all there is to know (think Theory of Everything), he would receive his Nobel prize, but science as an endeavor would no longer be needed, and his Nobel prize would be a useless relic ("just like that telephone"). People--especially those whose spend their lives seeking answers--need mystery.

reply

I interpreted it this way: For Professor and those like him, The Room represents discovery of the unknown. If Professor were to actually discover all there is to know (think Theory of Everything), he would receive his Nobel prize, but science as an endeavor would no longer be needed, and his Nobel prize would be a useless relic ("just like that telephone"). People--especially those whose spend their lives seeking answers--need mystery.


The Professor was there to blow up the Room, not to use it to win a Nobel prize.


reply

But he had also brought recording devices to document the Zone, his intent was to win a Nobel prize.

reply

I think the phone call scene was quite funny - as the man first answers the phone and only then realizes that there cannot be any working phone in the Zone. And it also adds to the mystery of the Zone as it makes it really unclear how the Zone affects the human technology.

Another fine attempt at humor was at the beginning when the man goes to the bar to have a drink, the Stalker says "No alcohol!", and the man says "Well, beer then". :)

reply

I think we need to revisit this scene since the ending reveals that he intended to blow up the place. Throughout the film, the writer made assumptions about why the scientist was going, but no one really knew. I suppose his colleague was reproaching him since he was going to go against their team's wishes of not destroying that place.

reply

LLTP, but the phone could be a figment of their imaginations or a result of secretive wish fulfillment by "The Room" (which they haven't even entered yet, supposedly). But who is to say what rules are rules in the Zone?

reply