MovieChat Forums > Prophecy (1979) Discussion > SELTZERS BEST- FRANKENHEIMERS FOLLY

SELTZERS BEST- FRANKENHEIMERS FOLLY


Prophecy was one of the first adult novels I ever read and remains one of my favourites- Seltzer creates a sense of believable horror and as near a truly original monster as could be hoped for, modern mutation meeting tribal history.

The film, however, is flat out dull and the blame lies squarely with the director, who was to later admit his dependency issues made this experience a blur for him.

His changing of the monster from a truly unique nightmarish chimera into something that looked like a badly burned mange ridden bear shows how little
he grasped the core of the story, and the attack scenes show a bizarre lethargy and lack of care or effort.

So many great ingredients badly undercooked and turned into a mediocre serving of bland 'horror'.

A real pity that someone even half interested didn't get to helm it.

reply

The movie was not perfect-too much gore and not enough information from the novel's ending, but I really enjoyed it and thought they did a decent job on the mutated bear. Grizzlies are one of my favorite animals and my heart broke when they showed the creatures. John Frankenheimer did a better job than he thought he did and I wish with all my heart that, before his death, he knew that. I do disagree with him thinking it was wrong for it to be brought down from an R rating to a PG rating(should have been PG-13). I don't know what was taken out to do that, but it was still pretty scary afterward.

"Do All Things For God's Glory"-1 Corinthians 10:31
I try doing this with my posts

reply

Too gory? The sleeping bag scene in the novel was brutal, it was nothing like that in the movie. That being said, I thought the movie version of the scene was pretty intense until the sleeping bag exploded. The bear creature looked great in closeups, I just wish they left its body to the imagination because it looked pretty silly when it was walking around.

I agree about Frankenheimer doing a much better job than he thought he did, but he did direct the original Manchurian Candidate. I guess this just wasn't up to his standards.

reply

[-] lm362 the PG-13 rating didn't exist in 1979, that didn't come around until 1984.

reply