The 'Pea' scene


The one scene that struck me was the little dialogue about Holmes smooshing Watson's pea. Does anyone have the EXACT quote?

I would appreciate it.

reply

Sorry no one has answered your Q, I haven't seen the film in over 20 years! Did U get it on DVD? Do ya think Blockbuster has it?



"The Film in which you are about to see is an account of a tragedy that befell a group of 5 youths"

reply

We rented it from Netflix. A perfect source for lots of now-obscure movies, but not all.

reply


good enough, I'll go to their site & search their obscurities! Cheers!




"The Film in which you are about to see is an account of a tragedy that befell a group of 5 youths"

reply

Holmes: Watson, what are you doing
Watson: I'm trying to corner the last pea on my plate
(Holmes squashes the pea)
Watson: You squashed my pea
Holmes: Well, now you've got it cornered
Watson: Yes but squashing a fellow's pea
Holmes: Just trying to help
Watson: I didn't want it squashed, i don't like it that way - i like it whole so that you can feel it pop when you bite down on it
Holmes: Sorry, i wasn't thinking

reply

Thanks! I thought this request would forever go unanswered. I nearly forgot about it.

LOL! Am I crazy or is that a pretty funny exchange?

reply

I think that the exchange is insane. It make Watson appear to be a bit of a maniac. He was`nt. In Doyles books Watson is a very sensible, reasonable and intelligent man.....not a fool.

reply

Oh for goodness sakes. Whenever there's a little humor with Watson

the literary Holmes purists go all apesh*t.

Sherlock squashed the man's pea. Watson had the right to be upset.

reply

[deleted]

Personally I dislike peas in all things, except in chicken pot pie. But, I thought it was hilarious. You can't squash a man's pea. It's not British. But of course, Sherlock wouldn't know that, would he? LOL

I think this is one of my favorite non Doyle SH.

reply

What's the matter w/ preferring to pop one's peas? We pea-poppers are not insane, we just know how we like to eat.

reply

[deleted]

Why was Watson trying to eat his peas in the manner those awful americans do? A proper Victorian gentleman would be trying to coax the pea onto the back of his fork with the aid of his knife and good old British dexterity.

reply

Perhaps he wasn't the snob you are.


"So what else is on your mind besides 100 proof women, 90 proof whiskey, and 14 karat gold?"

reply

Perhaps you need to develop a sense of humor.

reply

stiff ass bastard

reply

Interestingly Mason played Watson only if he would not be the Nigel Bruce like character -- so I would think he thought this wasn't a silly bit but something to show the relationship of the two men.

reply

The pea scene is wonderful.. abit of class mooched into the film...

reply

We enjoy quoting along those lines whenever peas are served. A great exchange between two pros. Natch, we don't do it as well.

reply

Hate be a stickler, but he actually said "biten down on it" using the 19th century manner

reply

This movie is available on DVD. I bought it quite some time ago and watch it regularly. I love Murder By Decree!

McQ

reply

Too right!


A gentleman's pea is his own private kingdom.


reply

Unhand my pea, Sir...

reply

[deleted]

To pea...or not to pea. That is the question.

reply

If you look under the "Memorable Quotes" link, you will find the dialogue word-for-word.

reply

All we are saying, is give peas a chance.

reply

Peas on you all

reply

LOL! One of my favorite scenes in this film.

Plummer and Mason worked very well together as Holmes and Watson.

reply

Watched it tonight(15/8/06).Best scene in the flick.Which is a distinctly wobbly tale with dialogue a mix of Shakespearean drama and,er,Abbott and Costello?

reply