MovieChat Forums > Midnight Express (1978) Discussion > Funny for a Country of Pigs

Funny for a Country of Pigs


You don't eat em.

reply

Strictly written for the movie. If the real Billy Hayes said that in court, they would have probably ordered an execution for him!

reply

You may be right but so what. Was a great line.

reply

I'm sure that according to the movie when he made his escape, the kindly, raspy voice judge was happy for him that he beat the system.

reply

Yeah, when he said that I immediately thought, "Is insulting them really the best strategy?"

He'd already been sentenced to life imprisonment, but the judges in this court at least were sympathetic. Of course he was in despair, but no point to burning what few bridges he had.



You might very well think that. I couldn't possibly comment.

reply

Yes, it was a dangerous thing to do. The judges could have sent him to a tougher prison, put him in solitary confinement ... there are many ways things could have been made worse for him.

What's more, it really deflated his subsequent comments about justice. They could have been quite poignant otherwise but were kind of spoiled by the context they were in.

reply

Watching it today, I feel a little embarrassed about that ranting. It's hard and offensive words. And like previous poster mentioned, the real Hayes never said that. All for the drama in the movie.

reply

[deleted]

Definitely. It didn't exactly endear him to me. He had done wrong and rather than acting like a spoilt brat, maybe he just needed to take his punishment and try and face it like a decent human being (whilst admittedly trying to fight it through the correct channels - not through anger and hatred)

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

Not a great line because it just does not work. It's nonsensical and unimaginative. There's absolutely no irony to be found in this sentence.

"Funny, for a country of humans, you don't eat them."

OBVIOUSLY

Loved the movie, though.

reply

Thought it was a great line that conveyed that his frutrastion and alienation had come to a head. Despite that, it doesn't weigh in the film's favour in the face of accusations of racism.

reply