Which is better?


Which film is better, "The Hills Have Eyes" or "The Hills Have Eyes" remake?

I'll post the same on the remakes' board, to see their oppinion as well, and compare them.

"I wished Her back but the dead adored Her, Even wild winds sang in chora for Her"

reply

I still prefer the original, but will admit that the remake is my favourite of all the modern remakes that I've seen and is worth watching out of more than just curiosity.

reply

Cheers. I'll be watching both of them anyway, but I thought I'd hear other peoples' thoughts first.

Thanks again.:)

"I wished Her back but the dead adored Her, Even wild winds sang in chora for Her"

reply

Original. Remake is pretty darn good though.

reply

Your hear and see on internet movie sites that how great horror films like The Exorcism, Halloween, Texas Chainsaw Massacre etc etc. I have seen them all. Some are good, some are over ratted, but none will scare and chill you more than this film. I mean the original movie. Its a unique film in a way that you most feel part of the onscreen events & at times kind of feel helpless and some what disturbed.

You should watch the original first. The remake i also worth watching. But the creepy atmosphere of the original wins the battle for me. An absolute great horror film of all time.

reply

Original but the remake is pretty good. The original is filled with feelings of dread and intensity not in the remake but the remake, in my opinion, has the better way for the family to crash. Instead of dodging a rabbit or whatever it was a trap. I dig that. Kind of like how they got people in Motel Hell which, by the way, I hear is being remade.
--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply

Yea. Original is better by a little. Doowopfan, how does this movie compare to the original TCM to you. It's both of our favorite movies ever.

reply

Well TCM is my favorite movie ever. Hills is around, eh, 30 if I had to rank them. How did you know that? My tag is a play on something the cook says, is that it? As for your question, it compares a little. Funny thing, I wrote Bob Burns once. He's the set director for this and Chain Saw and The Howling and asked him about how gramma from Chain Saw is in The Howling and he actually wrote back. I got his address from Tim Harden of texaschainsawmassacre.net. I couldn't believe he replied. Really cool. He died though.
But to answer your question, both are great. In a way, Hills actually deals with more grotesque subject matter but it isn't presented with as much in your face intensity.

--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply

I knew from your posts on the TCM board. and the quote. I think both movies are great. TCM definitely better, but they are both awesome. THHE definitely took alot from TCM though.

reply

As did "Motel Hell" which I also like.

--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply

I'm dying to see that. I've heard really good things.

reply

Oh yeah. It is great. I have that on a double disk with Deranged which is also based on Ed Gein like Chain Saw is. I haven't seen it in a while. I should pop that in. It is a nasty little flick. And it has Cliff Claven from Cheers in it!

--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply

Yea, Ive heard of Deranged, can't find it anywhere though.

reply

I prefer the original Hills Have Eyes, but I like the remake as well

Perfection is boring - flaunt the imperfection!

reply

After rewatching both, I definitely prefer the original.
But, the remake is the best horror remake I've seen.
And, I saw Motel Hell, which is awesome as well.

The Saw: Speaker of truth and defender of the entire Texas Chainsaw original series.

reply

And, I saw Motel Hell, which is awesome as well.

the worst part is im the biggest hypocrite of all. in my meats i used...Preservatives!

Meats meat and a man's gotta eat.

There are too many people in the world and not enough food. this solves both problems at the same time.

I loved that film when i first saw it. you know where i can find a copy of it?

reply

http://www.amazon.com/Deranged-Midnite-Movies-Double-Feature/dp/B00006 8TPD/ref=sr_1_1?s=movies-tv&ie=UTF8&qid=1326226323&sr=1-1

Motel Hell's always good for a giggle.

But the real prize here is Deranged. Now there's an underappreciated little film.

reply