MovieChat Forums > Faces of Death (1978) Discussion > Snuff movies do not exist.

Snuff movies do not exist.


For anyone genuinely interested in whether any of the footage in this film is real, I'd recommend the excellent 'Killing For Culture: An Illustrated History of Death Film from Mondo to Snuff'(Creation Books) by David Kerekes and David Slater. It has an extremely well-researched and highly readable chapter on the 'F.O.D.' series, as well as a definitive debunking of the authenticity of 'Snuff' and the Japanese 'Guinea Pig' series, among many others.

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Killing-Culture-Illustrated-History-Creation/dp/1871592208/sr=1-1/qid=1166054672/ref=sr_1_1/026-6350853-3118867?ie=UTF8&s=books

reply

Yes they do.

reply

Name one.

reply

I'm not on about a widely released official film of a snuff movie, that is never going to happen. I'm talking about films where the purpose is to see someone really die, which are not hugely released, but just independent.

They do exist, because there have been many reports of undercover findings of them and dealings with them. I remember a report where a man payed $250,000 for a video of a male child who was raped and then murdered.

reply

Wow. I'd like to learn where you heard that? That's quite gruesome.

reply

It was an undercover reporter on BBC1 a year or so ago if I remember.
http://www.ruthlessintent.com/board

reply

[deleted]

http://www.snopes.com/horrors/madmen/snuff.asp

reply

That only covers commercially sold snuff films, which obviously aren't out there. There ARE snuff films. There are NOT commercially released snuff films. Very large difference.

reply

"Name one."

Faces of Death.

reply

I wouldn't be surprised if there was an underground exchange of these types of things. Kind of like how Mystery Science Theatre 3000 fans pass around episodes of the show.

reply

http://www.ohlookaforum.com/sick-vids-f21/dnepropetrovsk-maniacs-ukrai ne-murder-video-guys-hammer-3guys1hammer-t102.html

The suspects' cell phones and personal computers contained multiple video recordings of the murders taking place. One full video was leaked to the Internet, showing the murder of 48-year-old Sergei Yatzenko. He is seen laying on his back in a wooded area, and is struck repeatedly in the face with a hammer held inside a plastic bag. One of the attackers pokes out Yatzenko's eyes, and stabs him in the abdomen with a screwdriver. Yatzenko is then struck with the hammer in order to ensure that he is dead. The attack lasts over four minutes, during which the victim lapses in and out of consciousness. One of the murderers can be seen smiling towards the camera during the video.[38] The murderers walk back to their car, showing that the crime took place only a few feet away from the side of a road, next to their parked car. They discuss the murder calmly, expressing mild amazement that the victim was still breathing after a screwdriver was plunged into his exposed brain. The suspects then wash their hands and the hammer with a water bottle, and begin to laugh.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Just watch any Isis beheading video.
Kenneth Begley anyone?

Or the one with the taliban guy diving headfirst off a cliff into solid rock below to prove that the west cannot defeat them!

A recent one in the USA was discovered recently involving a young baby - nasty stuff!

reply

ISIS beheadings, or really anything like that from drug cartels or terrorist groups aren't snuff by definition, since those are made for different purposes; (1) propaganda or (2) to promote scare tactics and instill terror--which goes against the grain of the general idea of snuff films, which are sold and distributed for profit (even if they are for sexual gratification, such as certain ones on the Deep Web that involve pedophilia and child abuse).

Our songs will all be silenced, but what of it? Go on singing. -- Orson Welles

reply

what about Armin Meiwes?

read about him: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armin_Meiwes

although the film was not released it still exists.

oh, i did a bit more research, i guess the film has to be made for the purpose of distribution. i take that back.

reply

snuff films DO exist.
The fact that users on this board cannot name one single film (and no one you know probably will be able to) is the reason the original producers can create them.
It is very likely they are produced "on demand" with extremely tight discretion and very high paying of money.

I mean what world do you live in? There has to be one or another "commercial" film but even if not there will be so much unknown snuff lying around somewhere in some sick freaks appartment.

reply

You are an insane madman....there's no such thing....Oh, but Lizard men exist..PLEASE!

reply

Yes they do... Oh yes they do!!!

The wierd guy from nearest sewer

reply

wow. that's pretty intense. i'd never heard of that until now. nothing like a little deep fried penis in your life. ha.

reply

Wooooah, I had half expected that to be the guy that had sex with a horse and died of internal bleeding. I completely forgot about this case :-D

I'm way too cool for a siggy.

Oh snap!

reply

Armin Meiwes did in fact make a video of him and Mr. B (the man he consumed), however, it wasn't made for the prupose of distribution, therefore it isn't technically SNUFF. If you're interested in learning more about Armin Meiwes' case, watch the film CANNIBAL (this is the closest thing anyone will ever get to the actual footage that was filmed). I don't for a second doubt that there is such a thing as genuine snuff floating around in the gritty underground world, it's just a matter of actually finding it and getting a chance to view it before the FBI finds out.

reply

"it wasn't made for the prupose of distribution, therefore it isn't technically SNUFF."

What about those silly terrorist who cut peoples heads off on video for the purpose of fear??? Seems a bit snuffy to me...

reply

The other part of the definition is that the finalized product is distrubuted FOR PROFIT. The terrorist videos have a different purpose,fear. Not money.

The closest thing I seen to a snuff as the 3Guys1Hammer video that's on the net. If that was ever sold for money; then you have a snuff.

You can avoid reality, but you cannot avoid the consequences of avoiding reality. - Ayn Rand

reply

I guess there is one "real" snuff film around. That poor kid that was killed by the Taliban----and released it to the media. Friend watched it on the web, warned me "Do not watch it"...Never did. Would be the closest you get (or the video of Sadam being Hung....

reply

It was filmed for political purposes, so it's not snuff by definition.

reply

That's what the song "Mein Teil" by Rammstein is about. Awesome band.

reply

saying snuff films dont exist just because one hasnt surfaced is like trying to say with authority that aliens dont exist. sure we havent come across any, but taking into consideration the size of the universe, its an educated guess that they do exist. the same educated guess can be made about snuff films. plus, police have caught people who were JUST about to go through with making a snuff film.
just because you havent seen one doesnt mean they dont exist.

---
AIM/MSN: SHaGGGz

reply

Yeah they do. Think about the hostage beheading videos that were put on the internet a few years ago.

Are you gonna bark all day, little doggie, or are you gonna bite?

reply

those arent snuff. snuff is made specifically for entertainment, those were politically-motivated terrorist activities.

---
AIM/MSN: SHaGGGz

reply

So that don't make it "a snuff" to you? I saw some of those movies and those guys looked pretty dead to me...

reply

yes, that makes it not snuff. not just "to me" but to anyone who understands what the term snuff film means. the existence of death captured on film is indisputable. so if faces of death fit the definition of snuff, there wouldnt be a debate about the existence of snuff films in the first place.

---
AIM/MSN: SHaGGGz

reply

what about all these "World's Worst Car Accidents" and things like that? people die on that all tha time and it's on TV, so clearly it's for entertainment.

reply

Once again, read the original post I made and do some research: 'snuff' is a really specific term for films that are commercially distributed to mainstream theatres/retail outlets, which contain acts of unsimulated fatal violence for the express purpose of commercial, mass-audience entertainment: all of the things that are being discussed around this topic (Armin Miewes, Al-Quaeda beheading videos, 'Worst Accident Ever'-style clip shows) may be seen as fellow travelers, as it were, to the snuff phenomenon, but THEY ARE NOT SNUFF!!! The reason this thread is titled 'Snuff movies do not exist', is because snuff movies do not exist.

Faces Of Death is almost 100% staged and simulated, so it does not make the cut either, I'm afraid.

reply

it doesnt matter if the snuff movie is being made for consumption in mainstream/retail theaters. it just has to be a movie that shows a deliberate killing of a person for entertainment purposes and profit. in all likelihood, snuff films do exist, despite the fact that none have surfaced yet (analogous to extraterrestrials).

---
AIM/MSN: SHaGGGz

reply

What you are saying is simply not true Shaggz...I urge you to do some reading on the subject.

reply

ive read plenty. there are multiple sources, with multiple definitions. you are no more right than i.

---
AIM/MSN: SHaGGGz

reply

There are several reports of people filming themselves killing others, if i remember correctly there was a case in Germany where two men were killing prostitutes, filming it in the hopes of selling them, so obviously people have tried it and failed, maybe somebody succeeded. There are over 6 billion people on the planet the odds that one of them killed another one, on tape, and sold it to another on are pretty good. That being said snuff by its very nature would be inconspicuous and highly secretive. is there direct evidence, no, but the fact is it is very likely that it exists somewhere. Plus if someone had actually seen one you think that they would get on an internet message board and announce it.

http://www.quotationspage.com/subjects/attitude/ it is the herm albright

reply

So your saying that nowhere has there been a murder on film, simply for some sick freak's entertainment? I'd be willing to bet that some serial killer at some point has filmed a murder or 2 for their personal enjoyment. And guess what, that would be a snuff film. Simply because you personally haven't seen one (or have and didn't believe it to be real), does not mean they do not exist. Hell, people have been caught putting videos up on the likes of facebook, where they had beaten someone badly (and in a couple instances, killed the person) and posted it for all their buddies to see. There have been convictions in those cases. Guess what. Killing someone and posting the video online, for personal amusement....is a snuff film. Dumbass.

reply

Dan.Exactly which source are you getting your definition from? The murder of soldiers and contractors by terrorists is snuff in every way and form. It's a real murder widely distributed for entertainment and profit. Snuff. Period.

I guess we found out his weakness. Bullets. ~ LL Cool J ~Mind Hunters

reply

I'll concede that my reference isn't relevant to the definition your using mistrdeth. I'm refering to a form of pornography.

The scientific imagination always restrains itself within the limits of probability - T.H. Huxley

reply

I think we can agree that snuff is in the eye of the beholder. I've found several sources that all give different definitions. Some of which are so overly specific that nothing is going to meet the criteria.

I guess we found out his weakness. Bullets. ~ LL Cool J ~Mind Hunters

reply

terrorists kill to further their own political causes, not entertainment.

---
AIM/MSN: SHaGGGz

reply

Wtf? Why would it have to be in theatre for mass-audience? That's stupid. By yur definition "snuff films" are impossible to exist. Because they'd never run a movie like that and they would throw the whole production team in jail (rightly so). There are however snuff films on deep web.

reply

I would say, that this doesn't qualify as "snuff".
I would probably define "snuff" as footage of a murder done only for the sake of filming it and selling it to people interested in that kind of "entertainment".
Thus, serial killers filming the death of their victims are not making "snuff", since they do they usually film for their personal use.
So, classifying a film as "snuff" depends on the motives of the person filming the murder.
---
Oh yes, snuff does exist. It's also called "smokeless tobacco" 8-)

reply

3 Guys 1 Hammer

Dean: What's in the Box!!

reply

The only thing I'd consiter to be a "snuff" are the graphic videos over on the 4girls1mouth site.I was paranoid for a while after seeing a beheading video.

"Reality is merely an illusion,albeit a very persistent one."
- Albert Einstein

reply

Yes.....They do, you can't possibly be that ignorant, and moreover, how can you even say that? They should NEVER be available to the public for NAMING, they surely exist, just as rings of pedophiles raping children exist, and have been busted, they're horrible things, but both are just so well hidden.

Personally I'm just fine with them being so well hidden, only done through videotapes and personal favors, the less I know the better, what I'm not okay with is you mocking them with the idea that they're fake. Countless people have been killed in these underground films, and you mock their tragic ends with your nonsense.

reply

There is no way to say for certain if snuff films exist because even the FBI has yet to find one, but that doesn't mean they're not out there.

Here are the legal crieeria used by the FBI to define a snuff film (horray for Wikipedia):

"...definitions include a number of acts (murder of animals, faked deaths, suicides and murders) which are filmed and only later distributed. In most cases the only motive to risk any exposure of the filmmakers' involvement is commercial."

Basically, the American Government states that a "snuff film" is a film of a murder (sometimes rape even, prior to the main event) made exclusively for commercial gain of the production crew and entertainment of whatever demographic they're selling them to. Anything not produced for commercial purposes falls into the catagory of "some psycho's home movie collection". The FBI and FCC state that these films are pornographic in nature, although I disagree. Explaination:

Not everyone that is drawn to violence finds it sexually arousing. If there are indeed people buying and watching these videos, I doubt that it's for a sexual urge, but more a primeval, violent urge to see someone suffer and die. Just because Sigmund Freud wanted to bang his mother doesn't mean that we all do.

Now, as for the possible existence of snuff, it would be a stretch to say either way. In a UK special about snuff films, a film director (not sure who) stated that "in this country [the USA, I assume] if someone is willing to pay money for something, people will sell it. If there are people willing to pay for snuff, then snuff exists somewhere".

There have been numerous arrests of people that were literally "about to make snuff films". Most of the undercovers that worked on these cases (normally posing as hired camera crew) stated that those at the helm of the project spoke like "this was nothing new to them" or that "they had clearly done this before".

I figure, if there are people making and distributing snuff films, they would like to remain as anonymous as possible, claiming almost untracable victims (prostitutes and transients, for example) and probably only sell to select, trusted clientele. One explaination is that there is no "snuff industry", just a few small clans of people that perpetuate their work for the very niche market they sell to. Another explaination is that the consumers would most likley want to stay as anonymous as the filmmakers. Having a huge collection of snuff films isn't really something that I'd tell all my friends about. If you look at the history of Sociopaths and Psychopaths, they are, for the most part, intellegent among other things. It could be safer to say that snuff films are indeed made and distributed by a very closed society of people that remain hidden via their own actions than it would be to say that it doesn't exist all together.

Look at the Freemasons, for example. Here's a society that has existed for hundreds of years with their own internal secrets that nobody outside their sect knows anything about. It's not inconcievable that snuff filmmakers exist in a very simmilar fashion.

reply

I don't know whether snuff films exist or not. Neither does anyone else posting here. If you did, and you admitted it you'd probably go to jail shortly thereafter. The idea that they might exist is something that I find pretty logical. I don't imagine that there are people who make tons of them and have complicated rings and whatnot to distribute them, but I would imagine that you can hire someone to make you one.

After all, back in the 80's Soldier of Fortune magazine got in some hot water becuase "mercenaries" would advertise in the back that they would commit murders and assasinations on demand. Some of those offers were legit, murders for hire were committed, and the law is now far more stringent as to whether those services can be advertised. My point, since we all know that it is possible to hire an assassin to kill someone you know, why should we assume that its impossible to hire someine to kill randomly and film it for you? I think that the idea of widespread underground rings is an urban legend, but how can any of us really know what types of private shady dealings individuals engage in with eachother on a ssmaller scale?

reply

Yes.....They do, you can't possibly be that ignorant, and moreover, how can you even say that? They should NEVER be available to the public for NAMING, they surely exist, just as rings of pedophiles raping children exist, and have been busted, they're horrible things, but both are just so well hidden.

Personally I'm just fine with them being so well hidden, only done through videotapes and personal favors, the less I know the better, what I'm not okay with is you mocking them with the idea that they're fake. Countless people have been killed in these underground films, and you mock their tragic ends with your nonsense.

The quote above from a previous post is very well said. Thank you, Revrant!

Innocence can certainly be considered a virtue, while ignorance can not, especially when an individual is making strong, definitive statements considering issues he/she obviously has no experience of and limited knowledge about, basing those arguments on rather narrow sources of research, and -above all- represents opinions as facts.

I have seen a snuff film - or more specifically parts of one. That was nearly seven years ago, yet it still haunts my dreams occasionally. I would unsee it if I could, and I neither wanted nor chose to watch it in the first place. I felt compelled to do so, however, in order to make at least a little difference in a world of exploitation and savagery that knows no boundaries. And I'm not going to jail for what I saw, simply because it was a part of my job. Grim, eh?! Only a couple of people working for the same organization as I was were able to watch all of it (somebody ultimately must, for how can you make an official statement considering material you have not carefully watched through...), and I readily admit I was not amongst those few.

It may sound like a cliché, but there are places in this world, where money screams louder than humanity and justice, and everything, anything is for sale: human body -female or male-, virginity and innocence, health and wellbeing and - even lives, if the cash overrules the risk involved. Just as real as those widespread underground paedophilia rings are some similar organizations that go a step further, combining sex and death. There have been busts, there are statistics (yes, I've seen some), but people really should comprehend, that these issues are not the kind of stuff that is widely discussed in public! And just for an exemple: FBI and other law-and-order forces never tell everything in their publicly released documents - for very good reasons, that are numerous: it can spread panic on occasion, it can jeopardize an investigation, it can give away too grim (equals realistic!)a picture of the threats lurking behind the facade of this corrupt modern society, it may put some of their own to an uncomfortable position or show certain individuals in a bad light...just general examples here, that apply to all release of information. (And I myself am not working for FBI and have no access to their files, only trying to describe how handling the criminal issues generally works. Neither am I taking a stand in whether it's right or wrong withholding information from the public, just merely stating it's a common procedure.)

The following chapter contains highly disturbing graphic details of criminal activities, so be forewarned before reading:





There are underground rings, that buy (from development countries mainly) and sell (to the wealthier countries) children of all ages, ethnic groups and both genders for paedophilic exploitation purposes. Similar human trafficking is practised on adults too, predominantly women. Sometimes the victims are kidnapped, yet more often they are actually sold by a family member, especially the children. The women and some kids usually end up in brothels run by prostitution rings, but some are directly sold for an extremely high prize to warped individuals, for sex-slaves or even for a single act of torture-and-kill. That in itself is not snuff, but it opens up some further possibilities: at a certain point the majority of these directly sold victims are inevitably murdered, either to silence them up or simply to get rid of them once they've become "damaged goods" (a terrible choice of words, yet that's exactly how the minds of these perverts work). So occasionally, it's being done on camera -the concept of "snuff" most often includes sexual violence and torture, that ends up with the victim being killed on tape- and is sold for sky-high prices through very discreet channels to a very limited selection of customers, who are known to be "trusted". Most commonly it serves as a means of sexual gratification to the consumer, and it can even be "custom-made" according to a certain individuals' requests - you get the picture, right, would not care to describe any more detailed than that...These criminal rings are for obvious reasons very difficult to uncover, but there have been some cases of people going to trial for possession of the so-called snuff. In some countries this can easily bring a death sentence. Certain aspects of the crime are very hard to prove with hard enough evidence however, and the success rate is shamefully low.





The organization I was working for concentrates on fighting all types of human trafficking in general, not especially or in particular snuff, yet occasionally that issue comes up in those circles, and that -along with the confidential files I've seen while working there- is the experience I base my statements on. Like the fellow poster I quoted in the beginning, I was highly irritated and infuriated by the combination of ignorance and arrogance in the original poster's attitude, and therefore I felt compelled to shed some light on a very disturbing and sensitive issue. After all it is quite offensive to the victims of crime ignoring the existence of practises that cost lives of the innocents. Of course when the thought of something is too macabre to be believed, it tends to be human nature to prefere to brush it under the rug. And it's okay not to know (even preferable in order to stay sane!), really, as long as one does not pretend to know what in fact is a modified truth. Let's all be grateful for what we have, for it's never for granted, and so many people are so much worse off than we ever were. That's a tough lesson I've learned the hard way...

Thank you for reading!

-N-L







"She left behind small traces of her time on Earth,visible only to those who know where to look..."

reply

Now that I think about it, it seems to me the OP has clearly confused two entirely different things. Since he/she is asking the second poster to "name one [snuff film]", and was in the original message referring to the "Guinea Pig" series and such. Of course these commercial, widely distributed movies have only simulated scenes of torture, death and mutilation. Certainly real snuff could hardly be distributed in this way, since murder is a serious crime all over the globe! It's true some people are wondering and spreading wild rumours about the authenticity of such horror and exploitation flicks, but those are silly accusations.

Though in the '70s there was a major scandal that almost lead to court after Ruggero Deodato published his ultraviolent film "Cannibal Holocaust", claiming it was "based on real events" and had been filmed in a way that supported his claim, and he actually brought the entire cast to a TV show to prove they were alive and unharmed, before the charges were dropped and his reputation cleared! This "all this really happened" phenomenon is a widely used marketing trick, because it adds to the tension and curiosity surrounding a film keeping people guessing. I also think the book mentioned (I have not read it, just assuming) concentrates on this kind of hype around the movie industry and reveals the facts behind the fiction claimed to be based on reality.






"She left behind small traces of her time on Earth,visible only to those who know where to look..."

reply

[deleted]

I guess you haven't seen Crossmack's videos over at YouTube.

He dies every time he switches his webcam on.

reply

[deleted]

BS is lol.

reply

:/ what do you mean, it was a movie left behind from the people who lived in your house before you did?

reply

Don't people have to pay for the death videos before they're considered SNUFF FILMS? You can film yourself killing someone and then put it on the net, but isn't it really a snuff film until you make so people need to pay to see it?

That's always what I thought, and I remember reading on Wikipedia a while back Snuff Films were a myth. Like what I said above hasn't actually happened.


For DEMONIC TOYS and updates on Full Moon Films:
www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

It's funny how many of people don't understand what a snuff film is. Yes there are tapes out there with people being murdered by other serial killers. This is not a snuff film! A snuff film is a video made for the purpose of selling it. So say some guy wanted to make some money and he kidnapped somebody and killed them and then tried to sell the tape of the murder. That would be considered a snuff film. Which doesn't exist.

reply

the 3 guys 1 hammer video along with about 20 more vidoes were intended to be sold to a web site before the guys were caught

Dean: What's in the Box!!

reply

Neat!

http://www.snopes.com/horrors/madmen/snuff.asp

What beautiful pubes you have, Mr. Bateman. So long. So silky.

reply

Thank you a million times over, stillanotherharris. I should have just started this thread with that link: maybe a lot of this assinine 'debate' could have been avoided.

reply

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, but it sure is suggestive.

http://www.csicop.org/si/9905/snuff.html

I love how the people here on this thread have accussed the OP of being clueless and naive and yet have not presented one documented case for a snuff film from a reliable source. Anecdotal evidence is worthless, especially when it's from a TV show.

reply

They do to an extent, exsist. There are people who document other people being tortured, raped and killed. To call a video or film snuff it has to of been made for profits and there have been on and off occasions of this.

There was a case of a guy who, paid Russian children money (about £3-£7) to make pornographic films which they ended up being muterlated and killed, then these where sold over in London, England. People paid £300-£4,000 per video and while people paid for it, demand increased and more videos would become available. This was only in 2000, a guy was wired talking to one saying 'does he die in this one' and the guy replied 'that's why I'm here' and I believe in Russia they are now out of prison due to space in prisons being crowded.

^^ I'm not saying this is true as I never saw it but it's worth a read in. SOURCE: Snuff: a documentary about killing on camera.

The reality is that people kill others and with tech. being what it is today (mobiles, cameras) it's easy to record the footage for enjoyment later on, also rings of people might form who sell and trade this footage like the child porn industy.

Now, 'recorded murders' (ie, documented snuff or non-profit snuff) do exsist, look at the war and all of the videos of people shooting each other, torturing each other and the infamous beheadings. I think when these are recorded it brings the general public to attention of what it is really like out there. Look at the war in Vietnam when it all started.

The reality is that underground, it is possible to find extreme porn and 'recorded murders'. Some of this might not even reach the internet.

Personally, I would define snuff as where a human is killed on academy (free or payfor).

'Snuff: a documentary about killing on camera' is worth a watch for anyone remotely interested in snuff.

reply

okay there are crazy sick people in this world, to say that you honestly believe that there are not people in this world who would accept money to murder someone and tape it, or that no one has ever paid for a video of someone being murdered is the most *beep* naive thing i have ever heard, the "leaked" suddam execution video was one of the most searched for things on the internet, ever.....yea its so unlikely in a world where people murder one another for fun, eat each other and rape each other fun that something like snuff exists is *beep* retarded....

reply

[deleted]

I read an article awhile back about how British Intelligence arrested a Russian man selling pedophile snuff that he and a few other people made and sold for as much as 500 dollars a tape. Just because this stuff is uncommon in the United States doesn't mean it's not floating around somewhere in the cesspools of the world.

reply

[deleted]