This is Chessy. But the Nu BSG is not that great at all.
While this is cheesy. I would take it over a shows that had nothing but narcissistic unlikable characters. I stop watching that show some time after the Space Mutiny episode happened. Where Adama goes f###ing ape sh!t because Star Buck goes back to their home planet. That when i notice the whole episode was just to manufacture some drama and didn't make any sense at all. Not to mention the whole episode after when Ensign Ro lands on Galactica. And a bunch of Over the Top Sadistic Bastards took over ship for some lame message about torture. No this show is not great. But neither was the New BSG. It was overhyped Soap Opera in Space. That was Not much better than Days of our Lives. Sorry but Someone had to say it. I watched that show for pretty long time and gave into the hype. Until i realized the only thing i liked about was the concept. Not the character or the stories. Except for maybe the President. But even she couldnt keep me watching. And it was probably good that i did stop watching. Considering that everyone turned out to be angels, ferry's or some Bullsh!t. And Frankly im happy the whole NuBSG is finally dead. Maybe someone can make something good out of it. Hopefully in a Movie. Not in Low Budget Prime Time Soap.
The old BSG is Cheesy, sure. But its a nice little family show about people who actually get along and try do to something good and positive. Instead of it being about who is f##King who and constant backstabbing. Like every Soap Opera on earth.