MovieChat Forums > Against the Wind (1978) Discussion > Did you have to be there or what?

Did you have to be there or what?


Is there anyone who likes this series who didn't see it as a kid?

I ask because I saw all the rave reviews on IMDB, so I bought the DVDs and started watching. I watched the first episode and skipped through the second, and watched two of the later ones just in case, but I was so disappointed I promptly passed it on to a friend.

So really -- did you have to have grown up there? Do you have to be Australian?

I think the golden age of films was in the 40s and 50s, and of television the 70s and 80s, so I don't think its age is why I didn't get it. And 1978 (plus minus a few years) produced some really great television series that I have enjoyed tremendously, like the Sandbaggers or Fawlty Towers or Not the Nine O'Clock News or Yes, Minister or The Secret War, or Blake's 7.

By contrast I found Against the Wind difficult to believe, it had some melodramatic acting, and a poor soundtrack that butted in at all the wrong moments. Not to mention the whitewash of the transported class and a vilification of the ruling upper class and officer class (which at times veered into what even the IRA would have approved as good propaganda). I understand that Australians have a soft spot for certain famous outlaws -- is that the same mentality? Anyway obviously Australian TV in the 70s didn't have the resources or experience for really outstanding shows, but it has moved on tremendously and has produced some quite good documentaries and dramas in later years.

So again, is it nostalgia? Were there a streak of good episodes in the middle that justify the poor ones I saw? I am looking for opinions for people who did NOT see the series in their youth and have just come to it now via the Internet. Thanks.

reply

No, you definitely do not have to have grown up there. I'm Swedish, and I love it. However, I did see it on TV as a child, so of course there is a bit of nostalgia involved, but I'll use my freedom of speech and answer anyway. I bought the DVD when it was finally released, and I was prepared to be disappointed since I had read many reviews saying that it wasn't as good as they remembered it, but I was positively surprised. I really loved it, and so did my husband. I guess the thing is that the narration is much slower than what we are used to today. Skipping episodes sounds like a really bad idea, since the episodes actually form a story - they are not stand alone episodes like in The Simpsons. You have to let the story grow on you, and not be too hasty. The love story is really romantic, and I cried floods.

reply

I heard about it when I was young, I love Jon English so I could be bias. But I loved it already, I am australian but that is not why I loved. I watched when I was about 9 or 10 when it was broadcast during the day and my grandma taped it. I too find the first two episodes a bit...well I wouldn't say boring but I tend to skip them but I know what happens in them because I have watched the series so many times so its alright, I start watching once Mary comes to Sydney.

But if there has been a substantial gap between when you last watched it and the present then I would recommend watching it from the beginning right through.



The only Abnormality is the incapacity to love

reply

[deleted]

I'm American and first came across the series when it was repeated in the early 1990s on TV in Fiji. I suppose having spent 13 years in Australia and learning about its history and people has helped me to understand the way the classes were portrayed. The Australians I knew deal deeply (to this day) with the after-effects of the rejection and abandonment that was perpetrated on them by the British. Most of Australia was not free-settled, rather British folks were forcibly transported - some for crimes as small as a child stealing a loaf of bread to stave off hunger - because the prisons were too full to accommodate one more person. Abuses did happen aboard ships, the children resulting from repeated rape were often forsaken on arrival by their mothers and taken in by the indigenous peoples, thereby growing up quite different from their British forebears. So all that impacts on a nation's identity and worldview, doesn't it? I found the series very enlightening, and from what I've learned from my friends, plausible.

I'd love to get a hold of a copy of it and watch it again. There's one for sale in the Marketplace at the moment, but I simply cannot spare the asking price right now. But I'll keep checking back to see if a more affordable copy pops up.

reply

A lot of Irish folks wer transported too by the British.

reply