Anne Bancroft at 46????


I really love ballet, I love this movie, and I adore Anne Bancroft. But I have to say that to this day, it still disturbs me that Anne Bancroft plays a lead dancer for a major ballet company at the age of 46....huh???

I hate to say this, but some of the rehearsal scenes were just painful to watch when you realized some of the teachers were the same age, if not younger, than Bancroft. She was an awesome actress, but come on.....

Now, I've never danced for a company, so maybe someone out there can enlighten me. Is it possible to be that age and still be considered the star of the company? Wouldn't it have been better to make her character a choreographer, teacher, or administrator of the company?

reply

Uh...isn't that kind of the point of the story?
For that matter, can you spell "Margot Fonteyn?"

reply

If Audrey Hepburn had been cast in the part, she looked very much like Fonteyn... Many dancers of the golden age of ballet danced into their 40's when their bodies allowed it...some continued even when it didn't. Melissa Hayden from NYCB retired at 50!!!!

reply

I saw Margot Fonteyn dance Cinderella in Washington, DC IN 1969. She was wonderful. Imagine my surprise when I read an article the next day in the Washington Post that mentioned she was 50. I never would have guessed that.

reply

I saw Maya Plisetskaya dance "Swan Lake" in 1974, when she was forty-eight. She was stunning and technically brilliant.

reply

It would not have been better to make her character something other than a dancer. A big part of the pathos of that character and her situation is that she devoted herself so thoroughly to that career, and is now at a point where she's been the top star for quite awhile, is still a star, but will have to move over and move on very soon. She's passed up some of what would have been possible options (including the man who wanted to marry her earlier, but no more) by clinging to her role as ballerina. It is not unheard of for a 46-year-old to still be dancing leads with ballet companies. Others have mentioned Margot Fonteyn (who had to continue dancing longer than she apparently wanted to, because of financial hardship). One legendary example is Alicia Alonso, who was almost freakish in that regard, danced all over the world, founded the Ballet Nacional de Cuba, and who is still pretty much revered by the Cuban public (and ballet lovers everywhere). Two more recent examples, off the top of my head, are Evelyn Hart and Sylvie Guillem.

reply

Darci Kistler just retired from New York City Ballet at the age of 46, after a 30-year career and some critical insinuations that she had already passed her prime some time ago.

reply

Bancroft's age was irrelevant in the movie. From her first entrance, she gave the impression of being a ballet star and that's all that matters. I'm guessing she had to lose quite a bit of weight for this movie, she was so thin. That, combined with her beautiful face, was enough for the role. She actually didn't dance, per se, at all in the movie. All her "moves" could have been done by anyone. In sum, I thought she was excellent in her role.

reply

In sum, I thought she was excellent in her role.

Yes, she was and HER CHARACTER IS THAT OF A MIDDLE-AGED BALLERINA PAST HER PRIME which is why a middle-aged actress was cast. I don't understand the OP's objection to this given that Emma's age and that of her goddaughter's are integral to the plot. Emma is being forcibly retired and is replaced by her goddaughter in the creepy choreographer's new ballet. It's noted that she isn't given much to do in the last piece in which she does appear because she really can't and is being carried by the company although her name probably still has pull.

reply

Oh, gosh, I thought she was absolutely wonderful in this role. And so elegant and beautiful, she just conveyed the image of a ballerina, even if she didn't dance in the movie.

I don't understand the OP's complaint, either, as it is the point of the movie that she is past her prime. She says herself about dancing Anna Karenina something like "…all the young girls will be in tutus doing a dozen…somethings [forgive me, I no longer remember the exact line], while this not-so-young lady will be covered to the floor and acting up a storm." And, of course, is humiliated at the end, when she thinks it is suggested that she dance Sleeping Beauty, but Adele tells her, no, that she could stage it.

reply

EXACTLY. That's the entire point of the movie. And Emma's character really had everything dumped on her at once, didn't she? Forcible (not to mention overdue) retirement, loss of a lover, and a jealous best friend who picks a cat fight. And cold comfort knowing she can continue to earn by staging a ballet in which she formerly danced the lead.

reply

I believe Cynthia Gregory also performed lead roles with ABT until her middle 40's.

reply


I think what the OP was trying to ask, is, is it highly unusual that a ballerina still be dancing in major roles at 46. And the answer is no, not really. It does happen.

She wasn't critizing the movie or Anne, just wondering if it was a believable scenario. sheesh.



...and I am just going to have to feel this way until I DON'T feel this way ANYMORE!

reply

[deleted]

Actually the OP suggested it might have been better to have Emma be something other than a dancer, and that's what most people here have objected to, because the whole plot is based on her being a dancer.

reply

Anne Bancroft's character was probably meant to be somewhat younger.

Maybe 41 or 42.

There is a principal ballerina in the American Ballet Theater right now who is in her early 40s (perhaps 42).

Her name is Julie Kent.

She was an adviser on the "Black Swan" movie.


reply

Here's Julie Kent's profile - she is featured in "Giselle" on Tuesday, May 31st 2011.

http://www.abt.org/dancers/detail.asp?Dancer_ID=23


reply

It's not so unusual - at least, not in companies which don't forcibly retire dancers at 40 like, for example, the Paris Opera Ballet does. Leanne Benjamin is currently, I think, 47 and still senior ballerina with the Royal Ballet in London, and her former colleague, Miyako Yoshida, although no longer dancing with the company, is still dancing in Japan, which is now her base. Plus there's Sylvie Guillem, who I think is 46 and is still dancing the odd ballet role - she danced Manon at La Scala to great acclaim only a few months ago. It does have to be said that all three women aren't dancing all the roles they used to when they were younger, though, either because they no longer feel comfortable with them or have just got rather bored with them. Further back, I think Lesley Collier danced with the Royal Ballet until she was about 50, and the American ballerina Eva Evdokimova and the Russian Ekaterina Maximova were still dancing certain roles at around that age. Benjamin, in particular, is probably a more credible 13-year-old Juliet than anyone else in the company!

Mind you, perhaps it's the 70s makeup, but I thought Bancroft looked rather older than any of the mid-40s dancers I've mentioned above currently do.

reply

Alicia Alonso danced into her geriatric years.






"Joey, have you ever been in a Turkish prison?"

reply

geriatric years.


LOL

In other words, when she was an old lady. LOL

reply

If you noticed, she was getting edged out when they told her she would be directing the next year's ballet. Ballet companies used to require the ballerina to retire at 42, but that meant they were s out of the company as principal dancers. Some went on to solo performances and guest star appearances. With today's better health care, vitamins and sports medicine, there is no reason a dancer cannot continue until she is 60. Margot Fonteyn did.

reply