MovieChat Forums > Slap Shot (1977) Discussion > A 52-year old hockey player?!?!?

A 52-year old hockey player?!?!?


This is the first time I'm seeing this film. I love Paul Newman. But he was 52 when this was made. We're supposed to believe a 52-year-old guy is playing hockey? Some players are still on the ice in their early 40s but then they retire.

reply

One Gordie Howe actually did retire from NHL aged 52. And Newman´s character wasn´t playing on the top level, where physical demands are higher, anyway.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

^This. Also, it's entirely possible he's playing a guy of about 44, 45.


---
Aren't you relieved to know you're not a golem?

reply

Mark Messier retired at 44. Also, Dunlap was a player/coach. Not that unusual.

reply

Gordie Howe was amazing in every way!

reply

Jagr and Brodeur of the Devils are in their forties and still rocking!!!

reply

The script called for someone in his mid-to-late thirties. (Al Pacino, who was about 37 at the time, originally wanted the role). So from that perspective he probably was too old. That being said, like most actors he looked young for his age, and he was great in the role.

reply

Can Pacino even skate? So glad that Newman got the role instead.

That said, they probably should've dyed his hair a little to make him look somewhat younger, as the role made more sense for a guy in his late 30's, with his career winding down.

Guys still playing in their 40's are usually the superstars who were phenomenal when they were in their prime, but can still cut it with the average younger guys.

reply

Can Pacino even skate?

I doubt it. Newman learned to skate when he was a kid, and when actors were trying out for parts as hockey players, he would race them around the rink as fast as he could go. If they couldn't keep up, they didn't get the part.

reply

Ha, then why the hell would he'd have even been considered for the part?

That, and I don't see him playing this role with the subtle comedy that's required of it.


Well, also, I can't F'ing stand Pacino.

reply

I read about this a while ago. If I remember correctly, Pacino was such a big star at this point, having just come off the Godfather movies, that he was a front-runner for the role. The problem was that he wanted full control of the production, including his choice of director - Sydney Lumet (Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon), which was a deal-breaker for the studio (not so much Lumet, but Pacino having control of the movie).

reply

I read about this a while ago. If I remember correctly, Pacino was such a big star at this point, having just come off the Godfather movies, that he was a front-runner for the role. The problem was that he wanted full control of the production, including his choice of director - Sydney Lumet (Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon), which was a deal-breaker for the studio (not so much Lumet, but Pacino having control of the movie).
Huge blessing and genius move by the studio if that's the case (and boy, you never say that very often). The movie was directed by George Roy Hill, who also directed Newman in 'Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid' and 'The Sting'. George Roy Hill was also from Minnesota and, if I'm not mistaken, coming from Minnesota he was a huge hockey fan and I think that is clearly evident in the film. And of course he already worked with Paul Newman on a couple of all-time classics, so it really was a perfect mixture.

Like it's already been said, Newman could feasibly pass for early/mid 40's in this film since he was in such good shape. Just because the script said mid/late 30's, it doesn't really matter - the point is still the same. It was a role meant for someone in the twilight of his career with zero shot at making it to the pros. Newman was perfect.

reply

Gordie Howe is a name mentioned already. Chelios retired just shy of 50 and to be honest, he could've probably made it past 50.

reply

Gordie Howe

reply

It wasn't exactly NHL (or even AHL)-caliber competition, either. The league was only a few steps above being semipro

reply

Slap Shot was based off of the WHA league. Gordie Howe played in the WHA into his 50s with his two sons on his team.

reply

Actually it was based on the Johnstown Jets of the North American Hockey League, which was a third tier minor league in the 70s. The sister of one of the players followed the team for a year and wrote the script

reply

the movie was pushing the limit at 52

reply