An argument in favor of Stephanie: Hector & Maria
Stephanie was supposed to be a bad dancer. If Stephanie was a good a dancer as Tony, then they would have legit. beat Hector and Maria.
Tony liked Stephanie because she was uninhibited on the dance floor. He didn't look at her that first time because he was wow'd by her dance moves. He liked the fact that she was owning the floor and dancing around all confident and carefree.
Otherwise, I thought the actress was pretty good. She was a typical NYC gal from the burroughs, accent, attitude. She had ambitions like Melanie Griffith's character in Working Girl. Except "she don't got no college" so she had to use her typing skills and a casting couch to get ahead.
🐾