MovieChat Forums > Orca (1977) Discussion > Who are we supposed to be rooting for he...

Who are we supposed to be rooting for here?


The Orca or Richard Harris?

I could ruin this film with spoilers, so I've deleted everything I've just wrote there.

Basically, who was the bigger "bad" guy and who was the "good" guy? Thanks there!

My Dynamic DVD/VHS Movie List - http://www.barryskelly.co.uk
From Scotland

reply

[deleted]

I'll try to make this easy for you: The whale is obviously a terrorist and has suspected links to Al-Qaeda. Its pod is actually a sleeper-cell working with Bin Laden to subvert the marine world's freedoms. Either you are with the whales, or you are with us!

"Rooting for"? Is this a football match? The world is not always so black and white as to wrap up individuals in "good" and "bad" guy packages. This film somewhat reflects that condition of life, and it has you confused. Wow... I'd hate to hear your response to a film with more than a touch of depth.

I recommend you go watch Jurassic Park (hint: the dinosaurs are the "bad guys").

reply

"I recommend you go watch Jurassic Park (hint: the dinosaurs are the "bad guys")."

Technically, in JP, the humans are still the bad guys as the dinosaurs are just being dinosaurs. I mean, none of the dinos went against mother nature and brought back an extinct species and put them into a zoo for entertainment.

Btw, I'm just having a laugh so don't this comment seriously.





Just my one cent since I can't afford two.

reply

"I recommend you go watch Jurassic Park (hint: the dinosaurs are the "bad guys")."

Technically, in JP, the humans are still the bad guys as the dinosaurs are just being dinosaurs. I mean, none of the dinos went against mother nature and brought back an extinct species and put them into a zoo for entertainment.

Btw, I'm just having a laugh so don't this comment seriously.


LOL, that's true haha

"I am the ultimate badass, you do not wanna `*beep*` wit me!"- Hudson in Aliens.

reply

Nobody, there are no good or bad guys in this movie, it's just a tragic movie.

reply

I agree. Both have suffered loss in some shape or form.

reply

Exactly.

What do you think this is, a signature? It's a way of life!

reply

Well, I'm still in the first scene - 30 min mark - and Charlotte Rampling (whose character represents scientific knowledge) and Will Sampson (whose character represents native wisdom) are both telling him what an idiot he is, so we may feel a twinge or two for Harris, but already I know he's a deaf fool who gets what he's got coming to him.

reply

Definitely not Richard Harris. I started out rooting for the whale, but he turned into an a$$hole too, so nobody to root for in this film.


YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!

reply

[deleted]

That goes without saying. Her uncast leg looked mighty fine!

YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!

reply

Is your signature from Crank Yankers?

Peace is not the absence of affliction, but the presence of God. ~Author Unknown

reply

Yes, that's from the awesome Special Ed character!


YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!

reply

Ha! I was always kinda partial to the crazy Vietnam vet character myself, "I think you are gonna hire that guy!" and the English perv Niles Standish, "Betty, I could get you on the guest list. How does that sound?"

Peace is not the absence of affliction, but the presence of God. ~Author Unknown

reply

Yeah, many good characters on that show!


YAAAAAY! Now you go, lady!

reply

I've always maintained this movie is a reverse Moby Dick. A man harms a whale and the whale spends his life trying to get revenge against the evil man, but in the process the whale becomes the very monster it's trying to destroy.

Of course Nolan doesn't put up a fight, he lets himself be killed because he knows he's in the wrong, so he's not really that evil.

reply

I've always maintained this movie is a reverse Moby Dick. - Lunchbox-3

I'm sure this movie was pitched to Paramount as, "It's Jaws meets Moby Dick!"

------------------
If I were a comedian, I'd incorporate myself so I could become a laughingstock.

reply

Orca and his family were the victims here, and his actions are similar to Paul Kersey's from Death Wish I & II!

Underrated film is effective and surprisingly melancholy; great score by Ennio Morricone.

reply

Nolan was also a victim. He had guilt over not doing anything to the drunk driver that killed his wife and son and wrongly thought the orca's actions showed more love for its family than he did for his. His wrong attitude made him a victim. I felt sorry for him.

"Do All Things For God's Glory"-1 Corinthians 10:31
I try doing this with my posts

reply

Honestly, seeing Dino De Laurentiis' name on the movie did make me think of this as some sort of weird Death Wish film.

I'm from Paris... TEXAS

reply

Oh, come on! The whale, of course, because nature wins out over man. Also, Charlotte Rampling is wandering around the Arctic in designer clothes not appropriate for below zero temperatures and you don't think that's cheesy? That's what makes this movie so much fun!

reply

I started out rooting for the whale, but he turned into an a$$hole too, so nobody to root for in this film.


the whale spends his life trying to get revenge against the evil man, but in the process the whale becomes the very monster it's trying to destroy.


Very well put. I lost all sympathy for the orca when he bit Annie's leg off.

reply